Super Mario World seems to kick New Super Mario Bros Wii's ass

I demand to know why I can't choose Super Mario All-Stars! It's unfair.
Out of those options, I pick Super Mario World, though I have yet to play NSMB Wii.

No its kicking everybody's. Super mario world is getting a massive league. I guess the nes kids are leaving and the SNES kids
are coming

I've already answered this before (right after NSMBWii came out) but I think it has to go like this

1) New Super Mario Bros Wii
2) Super Mario World
3) Super Mario Bros 3
4) New Super Mario Bros DS
5) Super Mario Bros
6) Super Mario Bros 2
7) Super Mario Bros: The Lost Levels

However, please note that I think they are all phenomenal games and I love every single one of them. The Lost Levels is the only one that I wouldn't recommend to people though.

I haven't played all of these, though of the ones I have played (3, World, DS, and Wii) I gotta say the Wii one wins out by virtue of the ability to play with multiple people.

Super Mario Bros 3 for me

Super Mario Bros 3, spent months playing that game when I was young, it's also the basic template for 2d Mario games, NSMBW comes second for me.

I still haven't played NSMBWii, but I'd give it to SMB3.

DS got a vote! \o/

New Super Mario Bros Wii is the BIG winner! I didn't expect that!