By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - 97+ Metacritic Games Elimination Game. //THE WINNER HAS WON

Tagged games:


Did Galaxy deserve it?

YES! 35 44.30%
Yes. 14 17.72%
No, but i'm happy it wasn't OoT. 9 11.39%
No. 14 17.72%
NO! ;-; 5 6.33%
no. Pitfall 2 is best 1 1.27%




Approved by Smeags. Approval request sent by Conegamer.

Rules (reserved for next game):

1. You may only vote once every 2 hours.

2. You may vote for 2 games at once, one positive vote (which will give +8gp) and one negative vote (which will give -16gp); Example: +ET, -OoT

3. Every game will start with 197gp. Once a game reaches 0gp it will be considered a flop and you will not be allowed to vote for it.



The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (N64)- Published by Nintendo in 1998. Metascore- 99.

Grand Theft Auto IV (PS3,X360,PC)- Published by Rockstar Games in 2008. Metascore- 98.

SoulCalibur (DC)- Published by Namco in 1999. Metascore- 98.

Super Mario Galaxy (WII)Published by Nintendo in 2007. Metascore- 97.

Super Mario Galaxy 2 (WII)Published by Nintendo in 2010. Metascore- 97.

Grand Theft Auto V (XBO,PS4,PC,PS3,X360)Published by Rockstar Games in 2013. Metascore- 97.

Perfect Dark (N64)- Published by Rare in 2000. Metascore- 97.

Metroid Prime (GC)- Published by Nintendo in 2002. Metascore- 97.

Grand Theft Auto III (PS2,PC,XB)- Published by Rockstar Games in 2001. Metascore- 97.

Halo: Combat Evolved (XB,PC)- Published by Microsoft in 2001. Metascore- 97.



Super Mario Galaxy  69gp


Dead games:

GTA IV: Went bowling with BluePokegon. It had 18 votes, 15 of which were negative and 3, positive.

GTA III: Got killed by the_lonegunman. It had 44 votes, 39 of which were negative and 5, positive.

GTA V: Was split in 4 by uran10. It had 57 votes, 41 of which were negative and 16, positive.

SoulCalibur: Got sliced by Jizz. It had 29 votes, 18 of which were negative and 11, positive.

Perfect Dark: Got shot by Darwinianevolution. It had 22 votes, 16 of which were negative and 6, positive.

Halo: collapsed in on itself because of b00moscone. It had 35 votes, 21 of which were negative and 14, positive.

Galaxy 2: Got kicked into orbit by Darwinianevolution (Kills: 2). It had 82 votes, 40 of which were negative and 42, positive.

Prime: got morphed into a tiny ball by Jumpin. It had 152 votes, 62 of which were negative and 90, positive.

Around the Network

Super Mario Galaxy 1 +
Legend of Zelda Ocarina of Time +

Perfect Dark -

You know it deserves the GOTY.

Come join The 2018 Obscure Game Monthly Review Thread.

+Super Mario Galaxy

-Ocarina of Time
-Perfect Dark

"Just for comparison Uncharted 4 was 20x bigger than Splatoon 2. This shows the huge difference between Sony's first-party games and Nintendo's first-party games."

+vote for Super Mario Galaxy and Super Mario Galaxy 2

-vote for Halo:Combat Evolved and SoulCalibur.

+ OoT

- GTA 3
- SoulCalibur


                               Anime: Haruhi                                                                                                           Nsfw Anime Thread                                     

Around the Network

+Galaxy 2
+Galaxy 1

-Orcarina of Time

I'm sure either GTA V or OoT will win this, and both of them don't deserve it imo.

+Metroid Prime


There's no need for the question mark. This thread is mod approved, don't you worry about that!

Looking good though, so here's my vote:

+GTA V, Halo
- SoulCaliber, GTA III


Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Ocarina of Time +


Soulcalibur -




NNID: b00moscone

Switch ID: SW-5475-6755-1986

3DS friend-Code: 4613-6380-5406

PSN: b00mosconi

+Super Mario Galaxy
+Metroid Prime


Official Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE Thread