Uncharted 4 vs Halo 5 vs Zelda U: Which will sell the most and be the highest rated?

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Uncharted 4 vs Halo 5 vs Zelda U: Which will sell the most and be the highest rated?

Clyde32 said:
ToraTiger said:
Clyde32 said:
MDT500 said:
Uncharted will be the highest rated, then Zelda, then Halo. Sales I think will be in same order.

Something's missing here...

I think you mean everything..

I was going to say logic, but that works.

LOL.  I like you guy, friend request sent.

3DS I.D : 3282-2755-4646

I make bad threads.  

SSB really went downhill after Melee....

Manlet Crew

Around the Network

Sims 4

Halo 5 will have the lowest ratings. Toss up between zeldaU and UC4 for which will be highest rated.

Zelda U will be highest rated, Halo 5 will sell the most

I can see Uncharted edging Halo & Zelda in both categories.

Around the Network

Halo 5 will definitely sell the most and I can see Zelda U having an extremely high Metascore due to it changing the Zelda formula quite a bit.... according to Aonuma at least...

       ---Member of the official Squeezol Fanclub---

My prediction:

Halo - 89
Uncharted - 94
Zelda - 97

Lifetime Sales:
Halo - 9m
Uncharted - 7.5m
Zelda - 5m


Halo > Uncharted > Zelda


Uncharted > Halo > Zelda

Would be halarious if all 3 game chose the same release date XD

Zelda will be the lowest selling of the 3.  UC4 & Halo 5 will battle for best selling.  PS4 has bigger install base, but Halo typically sells better.

As far as the ratings go, Zelda U & UC4 will no doubt be rated verry verry high just based on the two Devs. history.  Naughy Dog's last 3 game got 10/10 on IGN, and when is the last time there has been a bad/mediocre 3D zelda game??

Halo 5 is a bit of a wildcard.  H4 got good rateings, but the lowest of any mainline Halo Game.  But then again, it was 343i's very first game as a studio, and they weren't even all the way built up when they started working on it.  Now that they are a fully fleshed out studio (~343 people work there), and have had some experience making a game together & such, I think thier next game will be much better.  Still, because they don't have a long and reliable pedagree as a studio, we just don't know how good it will be.

Rating wise:
Zelda U
Uncharted 4
Halo 5

Sales wise:
Halo 5
Uncharted 4
Zelda U