By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Digital Foundry vs. The Battlefield 4 Beta

Tagged games:

PS3 vs 360

PS3: 1280x704 MLAA
360: 1280x690 FXAA

Both with dinamic resolution down to 1120x600 (that was the lowest resolution they get on output).

"The overall impression left by the Battlefield 4 beta is that DICE has targeted PC and next-gen aggressively, with the Xbox 360 and PS3 games visually way behind."

"In terms of the beta, Xbox 360 has a mild performance advantage, but we hope its texture issues are resolved in the final game. PS3, meanwhile, enjoys a completely tear-free game experience."

PC vs Xbone x PS4 (both simulated on PC)

PS4 Simulated: 900p
Xbone Simulated: 720p

The simulation was made dropping in resolution in PC plus the upscale to 1080p.

1080p: http://cfa.eurogamer.net/2013/articles//a/1/6/2/2/4/3/2/1_1080_copy.png
900p: http://cfa.eurogamer.net/2013/articles//a/1/6/2/2/4/3/2/1_900_copy.png
720p: http://cfa.eurogamer.net/2013/articles//a/1/6/2/2/4/3/2/1_720_copy.png

"Here's a resolution comparison showcasing native 1080p and the rumoured downscaling for console versions - 1280x720 and 1600x900. Judge for yourself how overall image quality is degraded at each resolution."

"Based on the testing we've done previously, the impact of lowering resolution increases exponentially the lower you go. A 900p downscale from 1080p isn't optimal of course, but it's acceptable, especially in living room conditions where the player is some distance from the screen. 1080p - or even 900p - down to 720p is far, far more impactful and should be backed by really good anti-aliasing. The tests here demonstrate clearly that 1080p is the preferable solution, but care needs to be taken if DICE decides to take resolution down much lower."

Final Notes

"At this point it's safe to say that the current-gen consoles fall significantly short in delivering anything like the full Battlefield 4 experience. The game is still very playable and fun in its own right but there's no doubt that players sticking with these versions of the game will be missing out on a significant element of the full experience.

While the lower fidelity visuals may be improved (remember, the BF3 beta was very unpolished), with the smaller player counts, and the lower frame-rates it's hard to recommend the game on these platforms if you have other options. Between the two, however, we feel that the PS3 version has the edge based on what we see from this beta code. The lack of screen-tear and improved image quality on PS3 offset the very subtle performance advantage on 360. Of course, this beta definitely suggests that the scope of the game was not limited by simultaneous development on last generation machines - something that is a concern with all cross-generation titles - and it's great to see that DICE is really going for it with PC and next-gen development. We'll have a look at the Xbox One and PS4 versions of the game in the coming weeks where we can finally discover whether or not the true Battlefield experience will be available to console owners, and perhaps put the resolution/frame-rate issues to bed once and for all."

http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-vs-the-battlefield-4-beta



Around the Network

The PS4/X1 comparison is beyond stupid.



           

Not much hope for BF4 honestly

Excited for SW Battlefront

Just hope it isn't BF4 on Hoth



It turns out that 900p looks better than 720p.



Do i get a prize?



Subie_Greg said:
Not much hope for BF4 honestly

Excited for SW Battlefront

Just hope it isn't BF4 on Hoth


I agree. Battlefield 3.5 more likely. And i cant judge Battlefront because we know nothing about it.



Around the Network
ultima said:
The PS4/X1 comparison is beyond stupid.

But they did without know what kind of AA will be used or the final resolution for both consoles... they just get the same PC and changed the resolution with the same AA.



Subie_Greg said:
Not much hope for BF4 honestly

Excited for SW Battlefront

Just hope it isn't BF4 on Hoth

How can you say that? :o

I think Battefield 4 is wonderful so far and I've only played the 360 open beta. Playing it on the X1 will be even more glorious!



BF4 beta sucks really bad. Most bland and boring bf game I've played yet.



Maybe the popularity of military shooters is dropping a little bit. Impressions of BF4 and COD10 haven't been too positive so far.



ethomaz said:
ultima said:
The PS4/X1 comparison is beyond stupid.

But they did without know what kind of AA will be used or the final resolution for both consoles... they just get the same PC and changed the resolution with the same AA.


That´s a new low for DF.

Or they have realy good insiders with 100% certain that the PS4 will be 900p and XOne 720p.

Not a surprise why people belive in BS when even the supposelly tech site jump the shark.