By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Leynos said:
LegitHyperbole said:

Does the Witcher count? We wouldn't have The Witcher 3 if it didn't start with that humble, awkward first game so my vote automatically has to go to The Witcher. If not TLOu, Uncharted, Souls maybe, Dragon age, idk it's hard to choose.

Eh. While the games were new in the 7th gen. IP itself dates back to the books. I guess it counts as a new game IP. Tho 1 sucked. 2 is improved but still a lot of issues mainly the 360 port Just a clunky game to play. Don't think people took to it until 3.

TW1 was terrible indeed and TW2 while better wasn't exactly a flawless gem that TW3 was but it was a start and turned into the greatest IP I can think of in gaming, hell TW3 wasn't flawless when it dropped either and took some patching to get it from exceptional to flawless. I believe The Witcher series has strenthened itself as one of the biggest IP in gaming in the time since the third game released and will sell up there in the top five including Multiplayer games when the next comes out, if it reviews well, unless something rocks the top five list in the mean time. I think of Uncharted and how that didn't really excel, it was good but not great, as with the souls games really iffy and awkward start. So since you make a good point that it isn't new really new IP. I'll go for TLOU, it hit the landing out the gate so well it made people critique the second over the slightest of little flaws.