By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
naruball said:
Darc Requiem said:
SecondWar said:
I never understood why Demi Lovato got on it, my best guess is to get young teenagers who saw her on Disney to watch the show. To me she just isn't at the right stage of her career to be being a mentor other singers, she also doesn't command the respect that other mentor on similar shows do, which is highlighted by this video. Also feel Britney Spears would suffer from similar problems, although probably to a lesser degree.


Britney's issue is that she can't sing. So doesn't have the necessary moral high ground to call contestants out.

Yeah, unlike Simon or L.A. Reid. Being able to sing has nothing to do with being a good judge. Christina Aguilera has an amazing voice, but is a terrible judge on the voice. She mostly talks about herself instead of the contestants.

Britney is the only judge who has the X-factor. She's someone with a decent voice and good dancing that has something special and can dominate music charts for more than a decade.


I agree, she has something special. I'll always have a soft spot for her