Quantcast
1UP reviews Animal Crossing: City Folk

Forums - Nintendo Discussion - 1UP reviews Animal Crossing: City Folk

I was hoping for something higher...



4 ≈ One

Around the Network
masschamber said:
outlawauron said:
masschamber said:
funny they don't penalize madden for the same thing, I think the city is a better update than a new roster

You obviously haven't played both Madden 08 and 09 to know they differences.

I don't know if the botched ps3 edition of 08 going to a non-botched edition of 09 counts as a major difference

Sigh. The MySkill settings and Madden Tests are both pretty big additions that really change the game the longer you play.

And Garcian continues his crusade against reviewers and the bias he wants them to have.



people must be really stupid to trust other people's taste.....
everyone has a different taste, LoL, i enjoy some games that get 5.0 more than games that get 9.0, so reviews mean nothing!!



Wii console: 0595 8808 5698 2709
Super Smash Bros Brawl: 1161 1357 5188

Mario Kart Wii: 1633 4506 4319

PES 2008: 1633 5820 0347

DragonBall Z BT 3: 3823 9760 9484

Pokemon Battle Revolution: 3480 2645 9186
Feel free to add me, and sent me a pm with your Friend Code!!

 

hanafuda said:
pichu_pichu said:
I don't like the last paragraph, that's like saying -

"do you want to collect all the stars you have collected in the last Mario karts"

or

"shoot the same enemy as the previous game" if it was a shooter game

why change something that's not broken and fun?


 

Or, Why buy the same game twice?

Because it's fun...

 

I'm w pichu on this.  Nobody complains when pes, madden, nhl or any other sports games feels exactly the same.  Why are they complaining about this?  Besides they added a lot more to the game.  Sports games update the rosters & add a few changes, not nearly as many as animal crossing, yet they still get rated very high, why?  Because they're FUN, and that's all that ever mattered.

 



arsenal009 said:
hanafuda said:
pichu_pichu said:
I don't like the last paragraph, that's like saying -

"do you want to collect all the stars you have collected in the last Mario karts"

or

"shoot the same enemy as the previous game" if it was a shooter game

why change something that's not broken and fun?


 

Or, Why buy the same game twice?

Because it's fun...

 

I'm w pichu on this.  Nobody complains when pes, madden, nhl or any other sports games feels exactly the same.  Why are they complaining about this?  Besides they added a lot more to the game.  Sports games update the rosters & add a few changes, not nearly as many as animal crossing, yet they still get rated very high, why?  Because they're FUN, and that's all that ever mattered.

 

 

absolutely true!!!

 

also, Animal Crossing is never the same game, it's new with every new game!!

the city is different when you start a new game, also the character and the animals in the city!!

even the items, the game is great!!   :  )



Wii console: 0595 8808 5698 2709
Super Smash Bros Brawl: 1161 1357 5188

Mario Kart Wii: 1633 4506 4319

PES 2008: 1633 5820 0347

DragonBall Z BT 3: 3823 9760 9484

Pokemon Battle Revolution: 3480 2645 9186
Feel free to add me, and sent me a pm with your Friend Code!!

 

Around the Network

Everytime a Wii game gets a low score, we have to have this "review system is broken" argument.

Everytime a PS360 game gets a low score, the game sucks, and didn't meet expectations, or something along those linies.

One more example of Wii Owners bias.

See, I can do that bull-shit too.



Erm don't reviewers nor gamers even consider for just "1" minute that there are like millions of WII owners out there who've NEVER EVER played an Animal Crossing game before.... hmmm?? No I guess not.



PLAYSTATION®3 is the future.....NOW.......B_E_L_I_E_V_E

Supporter of PlayStation and Nintendo

*~Onna76~* said:
Erm don't reviewers nor gamers even consider for just "1" minute that there are like millions of WII owners out there who've NEVER EVER played an Animal Crossing game before.... hmmm?? No I guess not.

How come no one cries when Madden gets a low score every year for not changing?

Aren't there more and more PS360s being sold every year, and by that token, more people that haven't played Madden?

The game is more of the same, and is reviewed as such.



Gobias said:
Hooray for lazy cash-ins!

 

Sounds like it, and it's a shame, really.

Nevertheless a lot of people should be able to enjoy it, but it's sad that Nintendo didn't put more effort in it. It also breaks a trend:

Mario Galaxy: Better than Gamecube version
Smash Bros Brawl: Better than Gamecube version
Mario Kart: Better than Gamecube version
Fire Emblem: Better than Gamecube versions
Metroid Prime 3: At least as good as the first Metroid

Animal Crossing: apperantly not so much.



DMeisterJ said:
*~Onna76~* said:
Erm don't reviewers nor gamers even consider for just "1" minute that there are like millions of WII owners out there who've NEVER EVER played an Animal Crossing game before.... hmmm?? No I guess not.

How come no one cries when Madden gets a low score every year for not changing?

Aren't there more and more PS360s being sold every year, and by that token, more people that haven't played Madden?

The game is more of the same, and is reviewed as such.

 

Dude what are u talking about?  Madden always gets in the 80s doesn't matter how long it's been out.  In fact i just checked it's rating on ps3 & it's increased every single time.  Also, Madden has been around for way longer than animal crossing.

 

Pls get ur facts straight before u comment.