Quantcast
Youtuber Banned For Viral RDR2 Video

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Youtuber Banned For Viral RDR2 Video

Faelco said:
COKTOE said:

I can't even....There's nothing funny about that. No matter the context. I think, if a dude put up a video on youtube where a man is punching not only a woman, but a feminist, he should be castrated with electricity.

Why? Why does the political views of the victim impact the situation in any way? You're fine with games in which you kill hundreds of people, but punching a feminist is a monstrosity? That's ridiculous. 

That's being super disingenuous. This wasn't about simply punching an NPC, it was about videos that showed the repeated murder and torture of this one NPC because she wanted her right to vote, a suffragette. He labeled her a "feminist" in his titles, and the videos got popular from the toxic sludge that spilled in to view and comment. Not to mention YT had the video constantly popping up in their recommendations, which started drawing the firestorm. Not saying the videos should have been taken down, but what he was promoting could have possibly been against the TOS. This probably could have been avoided if not for the inflammatory titles.



Around the Network
COKTOE said:
Faelco said:

Why? Why does the political views of the victim impact the situation in any way? You're fine with games in which you kill hundreds of people, but punching a feminist is a monstrosity? That's ridiculous. 

It's just wrong. Wrong and sick. Start out at a lower power. Let his screams wash over those attending his disciplining. Especially the children. Then ramp it up until his until his testicles  E-X-P-L-O-D-E. If he passes out, inject him with cocaine to keep him awake. You've got to be pretty fucked in the head to think what that idiot youtuber did was acceptable, let alone funny.

The video is surely not funny (I didn't even watch), but what you describe is a lot more fucked up.

Basically every kind of people imaginable has been killed in games already. You even have games like Civilization in which you nuclear bomb billions of people, but you draw the line at "feminist". In my opinion, this mentality is just wrong. "You can torture, mutilate, kill anyone except this kind of people I chose" is wrong. 

RJ_Sizzle said: 
Faelco said: 

Why? Why does the political views of the victim impact the situation in any way? You're fine with games in which you kill hundreds of people, but punching a feminist is a monstrosity? That's ridiculous. 

That's being super disingenuous. This wasn't about simply punching an NPC, it was about videos that showed the repeated murder and torture of this one NPC because she wanted her right to vote, a suffragette. He labeled her a "feminist" in his titles, and the videos got popular from the toxic sludge that spilled in to view and comment. Not to mention YT had the video constantly popping up in their recommendations, which started drawing the firestorm. Not saying the videos should have been taken down, but what he was promoting could have possibly been against the TOS. This probably could have been avoided if not for the inflammatory titles.

My point is: What if he did the exact same videos about, let's say, a sheriff? Or a local bartender? It would be just as disgusting and the same kind of unacceptable behavior. But no, some people think that It's wrong because "she's a feminist". It's wrong because of the actions, not the political stance of the victim. This is a messed up point of view.

Last edited by Faelco - on 07 November 2018

Faelco said:
COKTOE said:

It's just wrong. Wrong and sick. Start out at a lower power. Let his screams wash over those attending his disciplining. Especially the children. Then ramp it up until his until his testicles  E-X-P-L-O-D-E. If he passes out, inject him with cocaine to keep him awake. You've got to be pretty fucked in the head to think what that idiot youtuber did was acceptable, let alone funny.

The video is surely not funny (I didn't even watch), but what you describe is a lot more fucked up.

Basically every kind of people imaginable has been killed in games already. You even have games like Civilization in which you nuclear bomb billions of people, but you draw the line at "feminist". In my opinion, this mentality is just wrong. "You can torture, mutilate, kill anyone except this kind of people I chose" is wrong. 

RJ_Sizzle said: 

That's being super disingenuous. This wasn't about simply punching an NPC, it was about videos that showed the repeated murder and torture of this one NPC because she wanted her right to vote, a suffragette. He labeled her a "feminist" in his titles, and the videos got popular from the toxic sludge that spilled in to view and comment. Not to mention YT had the video constantly popping up in their recommendations, which started drawing the firestorm. Not saying the videos should have been taken down, but what he was promoting could have possibly been against the TOS. This probably could have been avoided if not for the inflammatory titles.

My point is: What if he did the exact same videos about, let's say, a sheriff? Or a local bartender? It would be just as disgusting and the same kind of unacceptable behavior. But no, some people think that It's wrong because "she's a feminist". It's wrong because of the actions, not the political stance of the victim. This is a messed up point of view.

Let's be real. It would not have gotten the same attention regardless. People were watching and cheering the video on simply because of what she was, a woman that wanted some basic civil rights. For some gamers, they feel this is something that calls for a fate worse than death for some reason.



Faelco said:
COKTOE said:

It's just wrong. Wrong and sick. Start out at a lower power. Let his screams wash over those attending his disciplining. Especially the children. Then ramp it up until his until his testicles  E-X-P-L-O-D-E. If he passes out, inject him with cocaine to keep him awake. You've got to be pretty fucked in the head to think what that idiot youtuber did was acceptable, let alone funny.

The video is surely not funny (I didn't even watch), but what you describe is a lot more fucked up.

 

Basically every kind of people imaginable has been killed in games already. You even have games like Civilization in which you nuclear bomb billions of people, but you draw the line at "feminist". In my opinion, this mentality is just wrong. "You can torture, mutilate, kill anyone except this kind of people I chose" is wrong. 

NO IT'S NOT!!! It's justice. Both you and Jason should be banned from the site for good for. Like the recent holocaust denier was. One and done.

User was moderated for this post

-Super_Boom

Last edited by Super_Boom - on 08 November 2018

Chinese food for breakfast

 

I guess no one can see my avatar. Goodnight everybody.



Chinese food for breakfast

 

Around the Network
RJ_Sizzle said:
Faelco said:

The video is surely not funny (I didn't even watch), but what you describe is a lot more fucked up.

Basically every kind of people imaginable has been killed in games already. You even have games like Civilization in which you nuclear bomb billions of people, but you draw the line at "feminist". In my opinion, this mentality is just wrong. "You can torture, mutilate, kill anyone except this kind of people I chose" is wrong. 

My point is: What if he did the exact same videos about, let's say, a sheriff? Or a local bartender? It would be just as disgusting and the same kind of unacceptable behavior. But no, some people think that It's wrong because "she's a feminist". It's wrong because of the actions, not the political stance of the victim. This is a messed up point of view.

Let's be real. It would not have gotten the same attention regardless. People were watching and cheering the video on simply because of what she was, a woman that wanted some basic civil rights. For some gamers, they feel this is something that calls for a fate worse than death for some reason.

This is stupid, for sure, especially cheering for that kind of thing. I'm not defending that in any way, don't worry.

The thing disturbing me is the way Cocktoe reacted, with basically "he should be tortured, castrated, killed", because "he did that to a feminist". The guy doing the videos should surely be put in a mental asylum because he clearly has psychological issues, but in my opinion it would be the same if he did the videos about any other kinds of people. Yes, the videos got more views because "feminist", but it doesn't change the fact that it would be wrong even with another kind of victim. "That guy should be banned because his videos showed a fucked up violence", yes. "That guy should be banned because his videos showed a fucked up violence on a feminist", no.



Faelco said:

This is stupid, for sure, especially cheering for that kind of thing. I'm not defending that in any way, don't worry.

The thing disturbing me is the way Cocktoe reacted, with basically "he should be tortured, castrated, killed", because "he did that to a feminist". The guy doing the videos should surely be put in a mental asylum because he clearly has psychological issues, but in my opinion it would be the same if he did the videos about any other kinds of people. Yes, the videos got more views because "feminist", but it doesn't change the fact that it would be wrong even with another kind of victim. "That guy should be banned because his videos showed a fucked up violence", yes. "That guy should be banned because his videos showed a fucked up violence on a feminist", no.

I'd hope you'd get it by now, but he was very obviously joking. I don't know how you haven't realized it yet.



Checked his youtube channel his last video he punches a man that hates racial and gender equality the video is titled punching hitler off cliff I think shirrako is only having fun doing things to everybody after murdering hitler he kills himself heres a link to his channel https://www.youtube.com/user/Shirrako/videos



My xbl:dx11332sega

My second Xbl:Segasaturnsan

My psn:Segasaturnsan

My Nintendo Friend Code:1302-4985-4999

My Steam:dx11332sega

My youtube Channel:https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC2EeIs1FP89Oz7du7IAEbqg?view_as=subscriber

He beats up the femeist in game because her views are rubbing the player the wrong she says men are stupid and such and world would be a better place if a woman was in charge turning it into a gender war. And in hitler vid he hates other races hitler lookalike also gets punched to death if you guys wanna see her views heres link https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UxA7nDaxi-s



My xbl:dx11332sega

My second Xbl:Segasaturnsan

My psn:Segasaturnsan

My Nintendo Friend Code:1302-4985-4999

My Steam:dx11332sega

My youtube Channel:https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC2EeIs1FP89Oz7du7IAEbqg?view_as=subscriber

But videos depicting assassination of President Trump are allowed? And violent rap videos? But priorities right?



                                  Gaming Away Life Since 1985