Yerm said:
okay, but ask yourself, really dig deep here on this one- was the sprite actually a perpetuation of a negative stereotype, or does it just resemble a Native American? was the point of this reference to poke fun at Native Americans, or was it just meant to reference one of Nintendo's oldest games? did removing the feather actually reduce the amount of racism in the world? and are you aware that in Japan, racism basically does not even exist to a point where many dont even understand the concept of it? and now really, REALLY dig deep on this one- could you actually foresee any impressionable child or teen playing Super Smash Bros Ultimate and then developing a negative view of Native Americans based on two frames of animation that vaguely resemble a man wearing a Native headdress? if you answered yes to any of these, you need a reality check. there are more pressing matters, more urgent issues, better things in general to complain about that this. direct that energy you have into something more than this, that could actually make a difference. because updating Mr. Game & Watch's animation didnt do that |
Wow, what a great way to miss the point!
It's not about protecting children or anything like that, it literally boiled down to 'hey, this is a racist caricature; maybe it would be better if we didn't include it since we see absolutely no benefit to keeping it in the game'. Believe it or not, MOST people who are labelled as 'SJWs' aren't actually offended by the things they speak out against but they do identify what is and isn't appropriate and aim to use their voice to enact positive change in the world.
This was a great example of that. Yes, some people went overboard (As people on the internet tend to do), but the response to those who had a problem with this has been equally abhorrent. Nintendo decided it had literally nothing to gain by keeping the headdress/feather imagery in the game and chose to take it out. Simple as that. Nothing to gain but certainly had things to lose as far as image is concerned. Nintendo does not want to be associated with the idea of perpetuating stereotypes and I don't blame them.
And I repeat, I was not offended by the imagery and wouldn't have cared if they kept it in. Had they left it in the game I would have shrugged and moved on because I see both sides of the argument (Keeping the homage to the original vs removing offensive stereotypes). However, I do feel they made the right decision and I do not see or understand how you could be so angry about this. All I'm seeing everywhere is about how 'PC Police win again' or 'SJWs ruining another videogame'.
Wow.
My Console Library:
PS5, Switch, XSX
PS4, PS3, PS2, PS1, WiiU, Wii, GCN, N64 SNES, XBO, 360
3DS, DS, GBA, Vita, PSP, Android