By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Microsoft vs. Nintendo vs. Sony: Seventh Generation Games Comparison.

NawaiNey on 28 June 2017

Please Read before posting:

 

  • This is a list of MS, Sony, and Nintendo games made for their 7th generation of consoles (XB 360, PS3, Wii).
  • The list only contains games with a 75 or higher Metascore (75 and up is what Metacritic considers "good", so it's not an arbitrary cut off by me).
  • These games are not necessarily developed by an inhouse studio, but the IP is owned by one of these first party publishers.
  • I have only listed games made for the 7th gen consoles, No remasters/collections have been included. (Jak & Daxter, Sly Cooper, ICO/SOTC collections, etc. are not eligable)
  • If you find something that should be in the list but isn't or vice/versa please kindly report it to me.

 

Microsoft 90+ Rated Games for XBOX 360

Sony 90+ Rated Games for PlayStation 3

Nintendo 90+ Rated Games for Wii

Gears of War (94)

Halo 3 (94)

Gears of War 2 (93)

Forza 3 (92)

Gears of War 3 (91)

Halo Reach (91)

Forza 4 (91)

Forza 2 (90)

Uncharted 2 (96)

The Last of Us (95)

LittleBigPlanet (95)

Uncharted 3 (92)

God of War III (92)

Journey (92)

MLB 10: The Show (91)

Killzone 2 (91)

LittleBigPlanet 2 (91)

MLB 09: The Show (90)

MLB 11: The Show (90)

Super Mario Galaxy (97)

Super Mario Galaxy 2 (97)

The Legend of Zelda: TP (95)

The Legend of Zelda: SS (93)

Super Smash Bros. Brawl (93)

Xenoblade Chronicles (92)

Metroid Prime 3 (90)
8 Games 11 Games 7 Games

Microsoft 80-89 Rated Games for XBOX 360

Sony 80-89 Rated Games for PlayStation 3

Nintendo 80-89 Rated Games for Wii

Fable 2 (89)

Project Gotham Racing 3 (88)

Halo 4 (87)

Dance Central 2 (86)

Dance Central 3 (86)

Project Gotham Racing 4 (85)

Forza Horizon (85)

Viva piñata (84)

Halo 3: ODST (83)

Alan Wake (83)

Crackdown (83)

Halo Wars (82)

Viva Piñata: Trouble in Paradise (82)

Dance Central (82)

Perfect Dark Zero (81)

Fable 3 (80)

Demon’s Souls (89)

R&C: Tool of Destruction (89)

Uncharted (88)

MLB 12: The Show (87)

Heavy Rain (87)

Flower (87)

Pixeljunk Shooter (87)

Resistance 2 (86)

R&C: A Crack in Time (87)

MLB 13: The Show (87)

Resistance (86)

inFAMOUS (85)

MLB 08: The Show (85)

Gran Turismo 5 (84);

Killzone 3 (84)

Motorstorm (84)

Warhawk (84)

Pixeljunk Monsters (83)

inFAMOUS (83)

Resistance (83)

Modnation Racers (82)

Singstar (82)

Motorstorm Pacific Rim (82)

Pixeljunk Shooter 2 (82)

Gran Turismo 6 (81)

Hot Shots Golf (81)

Echochrome (81)

God of War: Ascension

Gran Turismo 5 Prologue (80)

Buzz! Quiz TV (80)

Puppeteer (80)

Pixeljunk Eden (80)

Buzz! Quiz World (80)

New Super Mario Bros. Wii (87)

Donkey Kong Country Returns (87)

Sin and Punishment (87)

Kirby’s Epic Yarn (86)

Punch Out! (86)

Super Paper Mario (85)

Rhythm Heaven Fever (83)

WarioWare: Smooth Moves (83)

Mario Kart Wii (82)

Wii Sports Resort (80)

Wii Fit (80)

The Last Story (80)
16 Games 33 Games 12 Games

 

Microsoft 75-79 Rated Games for XBOX 360

Sony 75-79 Rated Games for PlayStation 3

Nintendo 75-79 Rated Games for Wii

Banjo Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts (79)

Kameo: Elements of Power (79)

Gears of War Judgement (79)

Blue Dragon (79)

Lost Odyssey (78)

State of Decay (78)

Alan Wake’s American Nightmare (76)

Heavenly Sword (79)

The unfinished Swan (79)

Fat Princess (79)

SIREN: Blood Curse (78)

Crash Commando (78)

Starhawk (77)

Motorstorm Apocalypse (77)

The Last Guy (77)

Dead Nation (77)

MLB 07: The Show (77)

MAG (76)

R&C: Into the Nexus (76)

Twisted Metal (76)

Singstar Vol. 2 (76)

Pixeljunk Sidescroller (76)

R&C: Quest for Booty (76)

Sly Cooper: Thieves in Time (75)

Folklore (75)

Metroid: Other M (79)

Mario Strikers Charged (79)

Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn (78)

Wario Land: Shake it! (78)

Kirby’s Return to Dreamland (77)

Excitebots: Trick Racing (77)

Wii Sports (76)

Battalion Wars 2 (75)

Total games with a good metascore= 31

31 Games from 15 different IPs.

Top 25 Average: 86.44

Total games with a good metascore=62

62 Games from 36 different IPs

Top 25 Average: 89.16

Total games with a good metascore= 27

27 Games from 10 different IPs

Top 25 Average: 85.24


Around the Network
paulrage2 on 28 June 2017

Forza 3 is 92. Not 94.



NawaiNey on 28 June 2017
paulrage2 said:
Forza 3 is 92. Not 94.

Thanks. Fixed it.



Turkish on 28 June 2017

Sony always wins baby, cant beat Sony

btw, you missed WipEout HD/Pure 89%, prolly missing others



NawaiNey on 28 June 2017
Turkish said:

Sony always wins baby, cant beat Sony

btw, you missed WipEout HD/Pure 89%, prolly missing others

Wipeout is a PS1 game. Pure is not owned by any of the first party publishers so don't know why you'd bring it up.

Thanks for the feedback though.



Around the Network
KLAMarine on 28 June 2017
Turkish said:

Sony always wins baby, cant beat Sony



tinfamous12 on 28 June 2017

It's amazing how well Microsofts big IP are received. They can make quality games. Like their main franchises are so good that millions still buy them. They just gotta realize that now and take that risk on a new major IP. I believe in them, i think they are doing better now, and i feel games on and next e3 will show it.

And make another Dance Central for heavens sake! Obviously its the best dance game available. I can't get with that Just Dance nonsense.

 



Vor on 28 June 2017
NawaiNey said:
Turkish said:

Sony always wins baby, cant beat Sony


btw, you missed WipEout HD/Pure 89%, prolly missing others

Wipeout is a PS1 game. Pure is not owned by any of the first party publishers so don't know why you'd bring it up.

Thanks for the feedback though.

It's been remade for the PS3 so it should be count too I think.

And sorry OP, I prefer Gamerankings

Edit: Remake is still a good addition to the console library. Why you have to exclude it?



A handheld gamer only (for now).

Conina on 28 June 2017
NawaiNey said:
  • If you find something that should be in the list but isn't or vice/versa please kindly report it to me.

 

 

Xbox 360:

Mark of the Ninja - 90%

Kinect Party - 81%

Kinectimals: Now with Bears - 78%

Hexic HD - 79%



NawaiNey on 28 June 2017
Vor said:
NawaiNey said:

Wipeout is a PS1 game. Pure is not owned by any of the first party publishers so don't know why you'd bring it up.

Thanks for the feedback though.

It's been remade for the PS3 so it should be count too I think.

And sorry OP, I prefer Gamerankings

Edit: Remake is still a good addition to the console library. Why you have to exclude it?

I personally have not played it. I assumed it's just a remaster since it's called "Wipeout HD" which was the typical naming convention for the remasters last gen.