By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Dear Esther: Landmark Edition could be one of those hidden gems.

 

Wright said:

Yeah, this game has been around for some time at this point.

If you want something like Myst...well there's nothing like Myst at this point, but maybe give The Vanishing of Ethan Carter a try?

As I said earlier in this thread, Obduction is probably what you're looking for if you want something like Myst. Here: http://store.steampowered.com/app/306760



Around the Network

Don't listen to all the harsh comments.

DE is one of the finest examples of what you can achieve with games when you re move the classic tropes that were inherited by the 80's and 90's, when audiovisual production was at an "under frogs ass" level.

There are no puzzles in the game and it is as linear as it gets, but if you like the genre, DE is a must. The soundtrack and puzzle-like story opens up in front of you a tragic tale of an everyday life that reached the brink of its own existence, and all the small (and on a universal scale insignificant memories) that it takes with it .

A true masterpiece, and a real indie benchmark.



Vote the Mayor for Mayor!

hunter_alien said:
Don't listen to all the harsh comments.

DE is one of the finest examples of what you can achieve with games when you re move the classic tropes that were inherited by the 80's and 90's, when audiovisual production was at an "under frogs ass" level.

There are no puzzles in the game and it is as linear as it gets, but if you like the genre, DE is a must. The soundtrack and puzzle-like story opens up in front of you a tragic tale of an everyday life that reached the brink of its own existence, and all the small (and on a universal scale insignificant memories) that it takes with it .

A true masterpiece, and a real indie benchmark.

I do understand some of the comments since I just came across the game.  But at a glance, it looks surreal and a work of art.  So it seem up my alley thus far.



LivingMetal said:
hunter_alien said:
Don't listen to all the harsh comments.

DE is one of the finest examples of what you can achieve with games when you re move the classic tropes that were inherited by the 80's and 90's, when audiovisual production was at an "under frogs ass" level.

There are no puzzles in the game and it is as linear as it gets, but if you like the genre, DE is a must. The soundtrack and puzzle-like story opens up in front of you a tragic tale of an everyday life that reached the brink of its own existence, and all the small (and on a universal scale insignificant memories) that it takes with it .

A true masterpiece, and a real indie benchmark.

I do understand some of the comments since I just came across the game.  But at a glance, it looks surreal and a work of art.  So it seem up my alley thus far.

The comments would be OK if The Chinese Room would have promised us a complex 3D puzzle game with tens of hours of gameplay. People forged their own expectations based on screenshots and got disappointed. Thats the same like watching a Lars von Trier movie and complaining that it didnt have enough explosions. You are right. DE is a piece of art, and if you can see trough that, get ready for a blast



Vote the Mayor for Mayor!

Lol it doesn't have any puzzles. Except maybe solving the puzzle of why you paid for it.

Also, these are the scum bags who used their company twitter account to call CD-Projekt sexist simply for having a an attractive woman on a piece of artwork.

Don't give money to assholes



Around the Network
hunter_alien said:
LivingMetal said:

I do understand some of the comments since I just came across the game.  But at a glance, it looks surreal and a work of art.  So it seem up my alley thus far.

The comments would be OK if The Chinese Room would have promised us a complex 3D puzzle game with tens of hours of gameplay. People forged their own expectations based on screenshots and got disappointed. Thats the same like watching a Lars von Trier movie and complaining that it didnt have enough explosions. You are right. DE is a piece of art, and if you can see trough that, get ready for a blast

Maybe I should wait for a flash sale.  We'll see.



the_dark_lewd said:
Lol it doesn't have any puzzles. Except maybe solving the puzzle of why you paid for it.

Also, these are the scum bags who used their company twitter account to call CD-Projekt sexist simply for having a an attractive woman on a piece of artwork.

Don't give money to assholes

Of course. Why not dismiss the work of a dedicated group of people simply because one person from that group seems a bit cuntish? What and iron logic you have there.

This is the reason I never trust user scores.



Vote the Mayor for Mayor!

Wright said:
Goodnightmoon said:

The Witness could do the trick too.

Well, haven't played that one, but as far as I know, 95% of its puzzles are the drawing-on-boards thing, no?

Yes, but you are also on a mysterious island that shows its secrets slowly while you solve it's puzzles. It has the mystery, the sense of wonder and puzzles, is the kind of game that a Myst fan could love.



Eh. I think I'll just link my Steam review here. I wrote it just after finishing the game, and I don't think I could sum up my feelings about the game better than that.

td;dr: It's a good experience but probably not worth buying. Your mileage may vary, of course.



Vini256 said:

As I said earlier in this thread, Obduction is probably what you're looking for if you want something like Myst. Here: http://store.steampowered.com/app/306760

Oh yeah, this one looks very cool indeed!

 

Goodnightmoon said:
Wright said:

Well, haven't played that one, but as far as I know, 95% of its puzzles are the drawing-on-boards thing, no?

Yes, but you are also on a mysterious island that shows its secrets slowly while you solve it's puzzles. It has the mystery, the sense of wonder and puzzles, is the kind of game that a Myst fan could love.

Well, yeah, in that sense it does have a Myst vibe.