By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - (Rumour) Rise of the Tomb Raider sells less than 200k in November (U.S.)

oniyide said:
AsGryffynn said:

No. All of them are set for 2016 and those for this year are digital only or first party... but why is it a problem when I answered your question, or are you telling me that Titanfall's success in the XONE is the Xbox 360 and PC's doing?



 

No the problem is you wont answer my question. I asked for an Xbox ONE exclusive, not timed, not on PC. Exclusive. I'm patient

Any? GoW Ultimate?

Thing is, all third party exclusives are TBA as of this year. There only 6 or so released so far and I can't find numbers for them, exceptions are the Kinect games that will naturally sell like crap? You're just picking something to suit YOUR argument.

Versus_Evil said:
oniyide said:

 

No the problem is you wont answer my question. I asked for an Xbox ONE exclusive, not timed, not on PC. Exclusive. I'm patient

 

His answers probably on a site hes decided to boycott so youll have to get it yourself XD hes a joke, dont know why you bother with him.

I decide to boycott a lot of stuff, but no sites are involved in this. I am dealing with a bunch of Xbox bashing brats though, no surprise there...

Dr.Henry_Killinger said:
oniyide said:

oh, im just having fun



Kinect Sports Rivals



Kinect games don't count.

And for acting picky...

http://www.nowgamer.com/why-dead-rising-3-is-an-xbox-one-exclusive-capcom-vancouver/

It was a exclusive. Not a timed one. Capcom decided to release it on PC after a year.

http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2014-05-08-dead-rising-3-sales-rise-to-1-2m-as-capcom-enjoys-profit-boost

It had sold a lot before the port was announced...

 



Around the Network

Rise of the Tomb Raider is showing some great legs in UK



@AsGryffyn lmao. TBA? thats the worst argument ive heard in a while. And DR3 is on PC so its not exclusive, doesnt matter when it came out. And if Capcom decided to put it on PC it probably didnt do so hot on xone, at least not as much as they wanted.

And I didnt cherry pick anything. I said a 3rd party exclusive that was only on Xbox ONE. If you cant just say you cant, but throwing timed exclusives is just blatant lying.



Dr.Henry_Killinger said:
oniyide said:

oh, im just having fun



Kinect Sports Rivals



we were talking more of 3rd party exclusives, that did well





oniyide said:
@AsGryffyn lmao. TBA? thats the worst argument ive heard in a while. And DR3 is on PC so its not exclusive, doesnt matter when it came out. And if Capcom decided to put it on PC it probably didnt do so hot on xone, at least not as much as they wanted.

And I didnt cherry pick anything. I said a 3rd party exclusive that was only on Xbox ONE. If you cant just say you cant, but throwing timed exclusives is just blatant lying.

You might say that for every game out there, but what kept them from the PS4? Also, they reported it positively and AS profit...

Not to mention that the original argument was this one...

oniyide said:
AsGryffynn said:

They deserve them. I already cited the reasons. The competition doing better is not related to how good the system is...



dont matter how good the system is, if it dont have th sales to support an exclusive it doesnt matter.



Me: But it does have them, just not this exclusive...

I explicitly mentioned this one, a timed exclusive and you never specified which exclusives. You shifted the goal post to limit me to games that are either unreleased or are first party.
Capcom was positive, and there was no spinning involved, since they released the game exclusively on their own volition. And they mentioned the ones that did negatively. Also...
Third best selling Dead Rising game. What it did before the announcement was only 200,000 sales behind what the series does in a single console and the gap has closed recently... And that was when the Xbox One was struggling to sell since it was more expensive than the PS4...

It did well regardless of your views on it. Capcom reported their flops and it did not flop, according to them.

To add insult to the injury, the only third party so far that we have sales information for, Sunset Overdrive, sold nicely compared to what Insomniac Games sell (Insomniac hasn't created a good game in years...



Around the Network
AsGryffynn said:
oniyide said:
@AsGryffyn lmao. TBA? thats the worst argument ive heard in a while. And DR3 is on PC so its not exclusive, doesnt matter when it came out. And if Capcom decided to put it on PC it probably didnt do so hot on xone, at least not as much as they wanted.

And I didnt cherry pick anything. I said a 3rd party exclusive that was only on Xbox ONE. If you cant just say you cant, but throwing timed exclusives is just blatant lying.

You might say that for every game out there, but what kept them from the PS4? Also, they reported it positively and AS profit...

Not to mention that the original argument was this one...

dont matter how good the system is, if it dont have th sales to support an exclusive it doesnt matter.



Me: But it does have them, just not this exclusive...

I explicitly mentioned this one, a timed exclusive and you never specified which exclusives. You shifted the goal post to limit me to games that are either unreleased or are first party.
Capcom was positive, and there was no spinning involved, since they released the game exclusively on their own volition. And they mentioned the ones that did negatively. Also...
Third best selling Dead Rising game. What it did before the announcement was only 200,000 sales behind what the series does in a single console and the gap has closed recently... And that was when the Xbox One was struggling to sell since it was more expensive than the PS4...

It did well regardless of your views on it. Capcom reported their flops and it did not flop, according to them.

 

  1. excluding or not admitting other things.
    "my exclusive focus is on San Antonio issues"
    •  
    •  
       
       
  2. 2.
    restricted or limited to the person, group, or area concerned.
    "the couple had exclusive possession of the condo"
    synonyms: soleunshareduniqueonlyindividualpersonalprivate
    "a room for your exclusive use"

 

your still avoiding my question as you still havent named me an actual exclusive. And even if that was my original argument (way to duck my question) thats one game. (which isnt even exclusive) which is an exception and not a rule, where are the rest of these 3rd party xbox one exclusive games then.

oh and can you give me an actual exclusive game.



oniyide said:
AsGryffynn said:
  • 2.
    restricted or limited to the person, group, or area concerned.
    "the couple had exclusive possession of the condo"
    synonyms: soleunshareduniqueonlyindividualpersonalprivate
    "a room for your exclusive use"
  •  

    your still avoiding my question as you still havent named me an actual exclusive. And even if that was my original argument (way to duck my question) thats one game. (which isnt even exclusive) which is an exception and not a rule, where are the rest of these 3rd party xbox one exclusive games then.

    oh and can you give me an actual exclusive game.

     



    If we are arguing semantics, then know that when people say exclusive, they refer to "console exclusives" unless they are changing the argument to suit themselves.

    And I did... Dead Rising 3 was an exclusive that sold 1.2 million. Quantum Break is an exclusive for 2016 and Halo MCC is a current one.

    If you want third party exclusives that remain exclusive and are not available on other consoles, you're out of luck unless you shove that cherry picking of yours. Why? Because under your definition, the PS4 has none either (even Bloodborne was a coop game developed on request).

    So this argument was moot from the start. So far, no console warrants a third party exclusive or has one that is worth it.



    oniyide said:
    @asgryffyn
    "With that logic the XONE deserves no exclusives!"

    no one deserves anything. But even if they did no, xone doesnt deserve exclusives. Why would they? the PS4 has sold almost twice as much. WHy would a 3rd party that is somewhat intelligent put an exclusive on a system that has that much less potential buyers? they wouldnt unless they were getting money upfront or they are stupid

     

    If you think this way, even the Xbone userbase is too large to ignore sales on that system so PS4 also wouldn't get exclusives from 3rd party.