By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - EDGE Next Gen Face-Off

ListerOfSmeg said:
Boutros said:
ListerOfSmeg said:

Controller - Wii U
Hardware - PC
Launch Games - Xbox One
Indie Support - PC
First Party Studios - Wii U
Second Screen Experience - Wii U
Social Services - PC/Wii U (Miiverse)
Cloud Tech - PC
Media and Services - PC
Development Ease - PC
So for me fits 1 X1, 3 Wii U, 4 PC. and a tie for 1 between Wii U and PC. Just my opinion comparing all platforms fairly

You're known to be fair.

I doubt you know anything about me but yes I was being fair. Unlike some I have no allegience to any platform so I always judge them without bias.

Sorry that the PC leads in mine but its my unbiased opinion.

And you have not on several occasions shown a completely obvious anti sony stance, don't forget to mention that when you tell us how unbiased you are.



Around the Network
colafitte said:
I'm surprised about the controller too, I was thinking dualshock 4 would be the winner


They obviously dont care about fighters and platformers. DS4 is better by far unless you only play shooters.



DerNebel said:
ListerOfSmeg said:
Boutros said:
ListerOfSmeg said:

Controller - Wii U
Hardware - PC
Launch Games - Xbox One
Indie Support - PC
First Party Studios - Wii U
Second Screen Experience - Wii U
Social Services - PC/Wii U (Miiverse)
Cloud Tech - PC
Media and Services - PC
Development Ease - PC
So for me fits 1 X1, 3 Wii U, 4 PC. and a tie for 1 between Wii U and PC. Just my opinion comparing all platforms fairly

You're known to be fair.

I doubt you know anything about me but yes I was being fair. Unlike some I have no allegience to any platform so I always judge them without bias.

Sorry that the PC leads in mine but its my unbiased opinion.

And you have not on every occasions shown a completely obvious anti sony stance, don't forget to mention that when you tell us how unbiased you are.

fix, he just put PC where there's no fit for Wii U or Xbox one



DerNebel said:
ListerOfSmeg said:
Boutros said:
ListerOfSmeg said:

Controller - Wii U
Hardware - PC
Launch Games - Xbox One
Indie Support - PC
First Party Studios - Wii U
Second Screen Experience - Wii U
Social Services - PC/Wii U (Miiverse)
Cloud Tech - PC
Media and Services - PC
Development Ease - PC
So for me fits 1 X1, 3 Wii U, 4 PC. and a tie for 1 between Wii U and PC. Just my opinion comparing all platforms fairly

You're known to be fair.

I doubt you know anything about me but yes I was being fair. Unlike some I have no allegience to any platform so I always judge them without bias.

Sorry that the PC leads in mine but its my unbiased opinion.

And you have not on several occasions shown a completely obvious anti sony stance, don't forget to mention that when you tell us how unbiased you are.


No I havent. I judge them all equally. Yes Sony has done things I do not agree with but I do not judge them unfairly because of it. You just see it that way because of your bias against anything not Sony. See I wont pretend Sony didnt get sued over the PS2 failure rate. I wont pretend they havent made mistakes because of some blind loyalty to them. Maybe you do and that is the real issue. Anything I have said about Sony has been fair, it is not my fault you cannot accept it.

If I have a bias against anything it is Sony fanboys, not Sony themselves.



ListerOfSmeg said:

Controller - Wii U
Hardware - PC
Launch Games - Xbox One
Indie Support - PC
First Party Studios - Wii U
Second Screen Experience - Wii U
Social Services - PC/Wii U (Miiverse)
Cloud Tech - PC
Media and Services - PC
Development Ease - PC
So for me fits 1 X1, 3 Wii U, 4 PC. and a tie for 1 between Wii U and PC. Just my opinion comparing all platforms fairly

 



Around the Network

Controller and games are those that I care the most about, so great!



Alright guys, let's get back on topic. Edge article on the next gen face-off, go!



...

Torillian said:
Alright guys, let's get back on topic. Edge article on the next gen face-off, go!

That's unfair.  We just got one of the most jaw-dropping comments of the week, like Darth Vader saying he has nothing against the Light Side (or whatever it's called) and you want us to ignore it ...

Fine, fine.

OT, um, some of these are meaningless without context.  Like, what if one of them won with a 51% to a 49%?  That would be quite different than if someone was clearly superior.



platformmaster918 said:
DanneSandin said:
Next Gen face off? Where's Wii U then? they'd at least nick the "First Party Studios" and "Second Screen Experience" ^^ so it would more be like:
Xbox: 4
Sony: 4
Nintendo: 2

second screen experience I'll give you but even if you consider Nintendo's first party better than Sony's they're more divided when it comes to handheld development.  Don't get me wrong I love Nintendo and I love Wii but the amount of big titles they've put out over this gen for me includes DKCR, SMG1 and 2, Zelda TP and SS, SSBB, and Metroid Prime 3.  So we'll give em 10 because maybe you liked a couple more than me.

Meanwhile Sony has given me Uncharted 1-3, Ratchet (ToD, Q4B, ACiT), Resistance 3 (wasn't a fan of the first 2 so I'll exclude them), Killzone 2-3, Infamous 1-2, Sly 4, LoU, Heavy Rain, Beyond, GoW 3 and Ascension, LBP 1-2, and we can count Journey, Flower, Twisted Metal, and Flow all as 1 since they're smaller.  So about 21 and I haven't gotten around to Puppeteer or Ratchet Nexus yet (obviously Ratchet since it's not out yet).  

So IMO IMO IMO they don't win first party for a console at least.  And in the end an  opinion is all an article like this is.

I find it odd that you include so many small games from playstation (or less known) but you do not include a single of the less known Nintendo titles. Don't get me wrong, most of the games you listed are great, some amazing, but if you're going to go into depht about the PS library, why not the wii? 

 

Some less known, but still great games on the Wii: Endless Ocean 1&2, punch out, Fire Emblem radiant dawn, Xenoblade(!), The Last Story, Pandora's tower and more. (Not all of the games listed are developed internally by Nintendo, but I'm pretty sure that Nintendo owns the rights to everyone of them).

 

OT: I'm going for the Xbox One, and from what I see here it looks like a good choice. Not sure if the controller one includes the kinect though, that might be the winning factor.

 



ListerOfSmeg said:
DerNebel said:
 

And you have not on several occasions shown a completely obvious anti sony stance, don't forget to mention that when you tell us how unbiased you are.


No I havent. I judge them all equally. Yes Sony has done things I do not agree with but I do not judge them unfairly because of it. You just see it that way because of your bias against anything not Sony. See I wont pretend Sony didnt get sued over the PS2 failure rate. I wont pretend they havent made mistakes because of some blind loyalty to them. Maybe you do and that is the real issue. Anything I have said about Sony has been fair, it is not my fault you cannot accept it.

If I have a bias against anything it is Sony fanboys, not Sony themselves.

You know I'm not denying that I'm leaning a bit towards Sony, if home consoles are concerned (portables are a different story), but I would say I don't have nowhere near as big an agenda as you have.

But keep telling yourself that you're unbiased if that makes you happy.  Let me tell you something though, people that feel the need to tell everyone how incredibly unbiased they are, are more often than not the most biased people out there and you're most certainly not an exception of that rule.

edit: Sorry, typed that before I saw the mod post, I'm done with this discussion.