As a Nintendo fanboy their E3 showing satisfied me, but I feel like it didn't succeed overall in showing why anyone beisdes the diehard Nintendo fans should get a Wii U. The two big disappointments for me were firstly, not having a fully 3D Mario platformer. Seriously a 2d/3d hybrid like 3D Land for the Wii U makes zero sense. Especially with NSMB2 and NSMB U still being relatively new games. The last thing Nintendo needed was a 2d Mario of any kind. And yeah I know it's not strictly 2D, but it's not strictly 3D either, which is what it needed to be. Those are always the Mario games that really show off what their system hardware is capable of. I don't feel like 3D World will do that whatsoever for the Wii U. It will very likely be an excellent game, but it also looks like it could easily be done on the 3DS, and would be a better fit for that system. The 2d/3d hybrid worked so well for 3D Land because of the stereoscopic 3D of the 3DS, which Wii U doesn't have. So that was a massive mess up on Nintendo's part in my opinion. 3D Mario is always their chance to show what their home console is really capable of, and I think they missed that chance with 3D World.
Second big disappointment was DKC Tropical Freeze being Retro's big WIi U project we've heard so much about the last year or so. Kinda tying back to 3D World, does anyone really need another 2d Nintendo platformer right now? Yeah they're great, but they're just becoming sooo over-saturated. And a DKC sequel was always last on my list for what I hoped Retro was working on. Even Prime 4 would have been a lot more exciting and fresh since its been awhile now for that series.
Was most happy with X, Bayonetta 2, Smash Bros, and surprisingly Mario Kart 8, which actually looks like a much needed change of pace for the series. The whole Mario Kart Galaxy feel definitely has me intrigued.