As a remake I'm not sure it counts, but I'd say Project Zero 2: Wii Edition. Incredibly atmospheric and scary.

Final Fantasy 13-2.

Binary Domain. The sales are atrociously low for a well crafted game.

FFXIII-2
Hitman
Binary domain

All by about 5 points for me...

and that's not really significant so really nothing. Lot's of overrated games though

I'm on the train for Binary Domain aswell. It was ghost in the shell kind of story and world with lots a good action and good controls and customization. Sometime reviewers do evil things like this and overlook the game by default cause it comes from Japan. It deserves better.

And then we hear them QQ that theres no new IP's. Go figure.

I'd like to say Xenoblade, but a 92 on Metacritic is good enough. I'd also like to say Virtue's Last Reward, but GameInformer just gave it the "Best Hendheld Exclusive" award yesterday, so it's getting proper recognition.

Kid Icarus is really fun and I dumped dozens of hours into its addicting (albiet a little repetitive) online multiplayer. The Vita-equivalent in terms of underratedness might be Gravity Rush, which I will try whenever I finally get my hands on the Vita. Probably sometime next year. Definitlely if it gets a bona fide price drop. Absolutely with a Sly 4 bundle (not gonna happen).

This!!

Resident Evil 6 really grew on me. Went from being the biggest disappointment of the year to being an obssession.

Darksiders 2

Rhythm Heaven Fever seems to be the most under rated IMO. Fantastic and memorable in many ways.