So I went to the store and bought Heavy Rain and Dead Space Extraction (shockingly great).  I then proceeded to literally sit in a chair and play non stop until I beat Heavy Rain.  Now first off amazing game, the ending was a little too much of a twist maybe (logic wise), but on replaying it, im sure it'll be more fitting.

But I must say I preferred Shattered Memories.  Maybe it was the subject matter, or the tenser gameplay, but it was slightly (ever so) better than Heavy Rain to me.

Does anyone else agree?  Why or why not?

im disappointed too in the lack of responses

i will say this tho, if the heavy rain guys made silent hill, that would beat both these games ;)

Silent hill SM, first it doesn't have laughably poor voice acting, which makes heavy rain very hard to take seriously for me, the scooby doo level predictable plot didn't help either, off topic anyone ever play that scooby doo adventure game for the genesis/mega drive it is pretty good
second I preferred silent hill's setting and story and the psychological profiling is really different with the game being influenced by your behavior, heavy rain is neat and it is nice to see some profile actually being given to an adventure game but it really isn't anything new regardless of what people want to insist and swirling menus are still menus
plus silent hill has the ufo ending

@masschamber

i agree, tho some acting was good, but like when you kill that dr as the girl (madison), and shes like 'alright you go girl!' its like what the fuck?

horribly acted, and written right there. like she was almostin hostel and shes all bouncey 'you go girl' after? totally almost blew the game for me there. worst part of the game easy

I have yet to play Heavy Rain but I /LOVED/ Shattered Memories

@tehsage

you will love heavy rain too tbh

also im surprised everyone is agreeing with me so far

go sh :)

I haven't played Heavy Rain either, but Silent Hill was my favorite game last year. And I'm surprised it has more votes O_O

Haven't played Shattered Memories yet, but I loved Heavy Rain. I just became a huge horror/murder mystery/thriller fan less than a year ago, and as you can see by my collection I've done some catching up but have a LOT to go yet! SH:SM is my very next Wii game to get though! I'll chime in then.

Until then I'll say: BUY HEAVY RAIN!

@cgi

i thought you were becoming a mod?

now youve got minions :O