So, right now I'm at 197.  This week I plan on picking up No More Heroes 2 and Mass Effect 2.  After that there's plenty of good games coming out, but I want my 200th game to be something spectacular.  What should I get?

Heavy Rain obviously

Heavy Rain or God of War 3( if you can wait till March). As you don´t have God of War serieson PS2 maybe you should get God of War collection on PS3.

Rainbird said: Heavy Rain obviously

I feel very "meh" about that game.  It could be great, but overall it seems like a gamefly rental.

You counted the number of games you've played?.......

God of War III since it's gonna be so fucking epic.

If not that Bad Company 2 because it's going to be explosive (literally).

What better than

FINAL FANTASY XIII

Will make a fitting 200th game!

Heavy Rain sounds good.

I have over slightly 700 games when I throw in all my GBA, NES + Older System Titles (Probably 300+ alone) so I'm with you on the insane games. I'd probably dump some of my older games but most aren't worth more then a few dollars so I keep them.

That would be simply impossible.  I've been playing games since the original Nintendo.  I'm talking about games I've owned.  Check my profile for the list.

You don't own Uncharted 2? Get it bro.