Wow, another list hating on games that people enjoy immensely. Just enjoy your entertainment people and stop saying that stuff YOU don't like is over-rated.

/thread

\ (opens thread back up)... also, where the F#*K is Mario!!!

I agree with everything except poke'mon. Poke'mon is incredibly popular but the reviews the games get are well deserved and not absurdly high (GTA, Halo, Call of Duty)

I agree with most of this list, especially Guitar Hero.

Halo games get scored acordingly. ODST and Halo Wars were not AAA games and that's why they didn't score that way, Halo CE, Halo 2 and Halo 3 were all AAA.

I mostly agree with that. Why include madden though. Its just football and everyone knows that, how is it over-rated?

I would have put Mario on that list. They're great games but I am a firm believer that Mario gets higher reviews due to nostalgia.

This is the best list I've ever seen. I've played everything on it but Pokemanz too.

FIFA and PES should be at the same spot as Madden

I agree, just all yearly sports should be.

yeah, I agree, maybe god of war shouldn't be on that list, or pokemon and ff

No way is FFX overrated
FFX is my number 1 FF GAME!