I dont think I've ever said anything negative about MAG, so I'm not looking for a plate of crow.
However I do have some reservations, as the logistics seem...unwieldy to me.
For example, how would clan matches work? Seems unlikely that any clan would have 128 participating members all at the same time.
Hell, I've had 3 other players on my team in Gears matches and just one random can screw up the best strategies...how can you control what hundreds of others are doing?
That being said, I missed the beta, or I would've found out for myself. Hopefully there will be a demo I can try out, eventually.