By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - Valkyria Chronicles OUTSELLS Lost Odyssey

jarrod said:

Carl2291 said:

 Then don't comment...

lol.  Like that's going to keep me from reposting more extensive trackers...

 

NPD (US)
-Lost Odyssey (360) 350,000*
-Valkyria Chronicles (PS3) 130,000

Enterbrain (JP)
-Senjou no Valkyria (PS3) 140,000
-Lost Odyssey (360) 110,000
-Senjou no Valkyria (The BEST) (PS3) 80,000

US + Japan total
-Lost Odyssey (360) 460,000+
-Valkyria Chronicles (PS3) 350,000

 

*figure from Jan 2009

I'm curious on the link for these.



...

Around the Network
XanderZane said:
They will never port LO or Blue Dragon to the PS3. SEGA should have ported Valkyria Chronicles to the XBox 360 and Wii. That could have been done easily. SEGA made tons of XBox exclusives last gen like Jet Set Radio, Shenmue, Panzer Dragon Orta, SEGA GT, Otogi 1 & 2, and all the 2K Sports games. Not sure why they didn't do much for Microsoft this generation. I still want Shenmue 3 and Gunvalkyrie 2.

Truth be told, I dunno if the game would've gained that much from going multi.  It seems like a hard sell, though the more tps-style gameplay might've made some headway with the shooter loving 360 base.  Though then again, Sega might not have been able to get that Sony funded anime then.

A Wii port would've been a bit more work, I think a better move would've been to make Valkyria 2 PSP/Wii multiplatform (PSP for JP sales, Wii for western sales).

 

Also, Sega did horribly on Xbox 1.  JSRF, GunValkyrie and Orta did so badly that Smilebit got shout down over it.  Sega banked last gen mainly on GameCube (with Sonic & Monkey Ball) and PS2 (with Virtua Fighter and Yakuza).



jarrod said:
c0rd said:
jarrod said:

Carl2291 said:

 Then don't comment...

lol.  Like that's going to keep me from reposting more extensive trackers...

 

NPD (US)
-Lost Odyssey (360) 350,000*
-Valkyria Chronicles (PS3) 130,000

Enterbrain (JP)
-Senjou no Valkyria (PS3) 140,000
-Lost Odyssey (360) 110,000
-Senjou no Valkyria (The BEST) (PS3) 80,000

US + Japan total
-Lost Odyssey (360) 460,000+
-Valkyria Chronicles (PS3) 350,000

 

*figure from Jan 2009

How recent is the 130k figure?

It seems like VGC always overtracks the RPG's...

Last NPD recent.  It's obscenely overtracked on VGC.

Source = Anihawk = Very sarcastic guy on GAF who has no access to NPD data.



jarrod said:
c0rd said:
jarrod said:

Carl2291 said:

 Then don't comment...

lol.  Like that's going to keep me from reposting more extensive trackers...

 

NPD (US)
-Lost Odyssey (360) 350,000*
-Valkyria Chronicles (PS3) 130,000

Enterbrain (JP)
-Senjou no Valkyria (PS3) 140,000
-Lost Odyssey (360) 110,000
-Senjou no Valkyria (The BEST) (PS3) 80,000

US + Japan total
-Lost Odyssey (360) 460,000+
-Valkyria Chronicles (PS3) 350,000

 

*figure from Jan 2009

How recent is the 130k figure?

It seems like VGC always overtracks the RPG's...

Last NPD recent.  It's obscenely overtracked on VGC.

I love how you STILL try downplaying the VGC numbers.

How about this one? It's obscenely undertracked on NPD. Never see you spouting that one do we?



                            

ps3_jrpg_gamer said:
first of all
NPD is from jan 2009 A YEAR OLD
130,000 in jan 2009 VC sales picked up since april nothing wrong

No, the Jan 2009 leak had VC at 74k.   The 130k is from November (not last NPD, sorry).



Around the Network
ElGranCabeza said:
jarrod said:
c0rd said:
jarrod said:

Carl2291 said:

 Then don't comment...

lol.  Like that's going to keep me from reposting more extensive trackers...

 

NPD (US)
-Lost Odyssey (360) 350,000*
-Valkyria Chronicles (PS3) 130,000

Enterbrain (JP)
-Senjou no Valkyria (PS3) 140,000
-Lost Odyssey (360) 110,000
-Senjou no Valkyria (The BEST) (PS3) 80,000

US + Japan total
-Lost Odyssey (360) 460,000+
-Valkyria Chronicles (PS3) 350,000

 

*figure from Jan 2009

How recent is the 130k figure?

It seems like VGC always overtracks the RPG's...

Last NPD recent.  It's obscenely overtracked on VGC.

Source = Anihawk = Very sarcastic guy on GAF who has no access to NPD data.

Er... Ani's the source of like half the NPD leaks on the internet.  People at GAF literally ask him for the numbers...

He's also the original source for the DSE leak, the Spirit Tracks leak, RE DSC leak, FFCC leak...



jarrod said:
ElGranCabeza said:
jarrod said:
c0rd said:
jarrod said:

Carl2291 said:

 Then don't comment...

lol.  Like that's going to keep me from reposting more extensive trackers...

 

NPD (US)
-Lost Odyssey (360) 350,000*
-Valkyria Chronicles (PS3) 130,000

Enterbrain (JP)
-Senjou no Valkyria (PS3) 140,000
-Lost Odyssey (360) 110,000
-Senjou no Valkyria (The BEST) (PS3) 80,000

US + Japan total
-Lost Odyssey (360) 460,000+
-Valkyria Chronicles (PS3) 350,000

 

*figure from Jan 2009

How recent is the 130k figure?

It seems like VGC always overtracks the RPG's...

Last NPD recent.  It's obscenely overtracked on VGC.

Source = Anihawk = Very sarcastic guy on GAF who has no access to NPD data.

Er... Ani's the source of like half the NPD leaks on the internet.  People at GAF literally ask him for the numbers...

He's also the original source for the DSE leak, the Spirit Tracks leak, RE DSC leak, FFCC leak...

You're thinking of creamsugar. Anihawk does not have access to NPD data, not unless he very recently got access to it.



Carl2291 said:
jarrod said:
c0rd said:
jarrod said:

Carl2291 said:

 Then don't comment...

lol.  Like that's going to keep me from reposting more extensive trackers...

 

NPD (US)
-Lost Odyssey (360) 350,000*
-Valkyria Chronicles (PS3) 130,000

Enterbrain (JP)
-Senjou no Valkyria (PS3) 140,000
-Lost Odyssey (360) 110,000
-Senjou no Valkyria (The BEST) (PS3) 80,000

US + Japan total
-Lost Odyssey (360) 460,000+
-Valkyria Chronicles (PS3) 350,000

 

*figure from Jan 2009

How recent is the 130k figure?

It seems like VGC always overtracks the RPG's...

Last NPD recent.  It's obscenely overtracked on VGC.

I love how you STILL try downplaying the VGC numbers.

How about this one? It's obscenely undertracked on NPD. Never see you spouting that one do we?

I am the downplaya! ;)

But I'll always go with whoever has greater coverage, it just makes sense.  VGC tends to overtrack generally with the smaller stuff, but their VC numbers are way above and beyond the usual discrepancies.  We'll know for sure whenever we get any shipment numbers out of Sega, which probably won;t happen until the series hits the million milestone...



ElGranCabeza said:
jarrod said:
ElGranCabeza said:
jarrod said:
c0rd said:
jarrod said:

Carl2291 said:

 Then don't comment...

lol.  Like that's going to keep me from reposting more extensive trackers...

 

NPD (US)
-Lost Odyssey (360) 350,000*
-Valkyria Chronicles (PS3) 130,000

Enterbrain (JP)
-Senjou no Valkyria (PS3) 140,000
-Lost Odyssey (360) 110,000
-Senjou no Valkyria (The BEST) (PS3) 80,000

US + Japan total
-Lost Odyssey (360) 460,000+
-Valkyria Chronicles (PS3) 350,000

 

*figure from Jan 2009

How recent is the 130k figure?

It seems like VGC always overtracks the RPG's...

Last NPD recent.  It's obscenely overtracked on VGC.

Source = Anihawk = Very sarcastic guy on GAF who has no access to NPD data.

Er... Ani's the source of like half the NPD leaks on the internet.  People at GAF literally ask him for the numbers...

He's also the original source for the DSE leak, the Spirit Tracks leak, RE DSC leak, FFCC leak...

You're thinking of creamsugar. Anihawk does not have access to NPD data, not unless he very recently got access to it.

Nope, Ani leaked ALL those.  He's basically taken over for CS since this last summer... he and several other longtime GAFers share the leak.



Well we just need VC2 to sell 200k week one then