No, and I'll tell you the reason.

9 letter word.

I never said innovation itself was bad. I just want the things there to back it up. FF12, at its core, was not a bad game. However, I do disagree with swapping characters out at will, especially during a fight, I hated the gambit system and thought it was too limiting, and the license grid was annoying, and in the end just made the character abilities horribly generic. If the gameplay itself were better, I probably would have it up with the SNES games for quality. Unfortunately, it's a risk that one takes with innovation. Some things work out to me. (Learning abilities/spells from equipment in FF9, for instance.) Other things are, well, a dud. (Just as long as the draw system NEVER comes back.)

Everyone has their own opinion about XII, but I'll say this. The battle system is NOT limiting, lol. It took me 2 playthroughs and over 160 hours to realize it, but XII's battle system is limitless....

...it just requires unbelievable dedication.

I think you got into where my issue is. It takes too much dedication, to the point where for me, it's obsession, not dedication. I'm not a skilled programmer by any means, but I did do some basics for it. I want more than a max of 12 lines. Late in the game, setting up my healing spells the way I would like them would use half the slots! And that's before all the check conditions to attack, use magic, items, etc. I did not like having to unlock the extra lines on the license grid (tying those problems together), and finding (and buying) the words that I want is not a sensical idea to me. Or, there's the fact that not everything I wanted to do was availiable. Say, "If enemy level > player level + 5, ignore." Sure, if I were willing to change it for every different enemy I see, it would work. But then it's a programming game, not an RPG. Just give me back control of my characters, and I'll be happy.

But yes, as you said, people will see it different ways. That level of micromanagement is not something I want to do, whereas others, like yourself, either take things that I see as a different problem, or are willing to do said micromanaging. It doesn't mean that either of us is wrong, as it's just different playstyles. But it's why I personally still can't put 12 in the same league as 4-6.

I want them to go back to the oldschool FF's.

damn it it's over 8 year since I enjoyed a FF game( not counting remakes)

you might want to change your sig, you will get told off for that (moderation) not being mean.

On Topic: I agree this will get a score of over 90% but does anyone else feel it's all been downhill since FFX was made??

I've had it for some time now.

No, I don't think it will get over 90%. It might have good scores for graphics/presentation, but gameplay will drag it down.

I'm willing to bet it's going to be somewhere around 88-90.

85+