Toad - 9
Snake - 7
Cloud - 2
Mario - 2
Sonic the Hedgehog - 1
Link - 1
Prince - 1
Guybrush Threepwood - 1
Madison Paige - 1
Ms. Pac-Man - 1
Gordon Freeman - 1
Reverend Ray - 1
Kratos - 1

I added Kratos back in for you. Honestly I added Toad because he is equally as legendary as any of the other characters listed here (except someone had the nerve to add Mario)

Also, Toad has been sold in various games totalling over 200m sales. Not many video characters can claim such fame.

Snake - 9
Toad - 9
Cloud - 2
Mario - 2
Sonic the Hedgehog - 1
Link - 1
Prince - 1
Guybrush Threepwood - 1
Madison Paige - 1
Ms. Pac-Man - 1
Gordon Freeman - 1
Reverend Ray - 1
Kratos - 1

My vote for Snake was removed last time. How dare they remove it!

Toad - 8
Snake - 6
Gordon Freeman - 2
Cloud - 2
Sonic the Hedgehog - 1
Link - 1
Prince - 1
Guybrush Threepwood - 1
Madison Paige - 1
Ms. Pac-Man - 1
Mario - 2
Reverend Ray - 1

I removed one from Snake because someone can't add on this forum and ended up giving him 2 at one point.

how dare you vote for anyone but toad

Toad - 10
Snake - 9
Gordon Freeman - 2
Cloud - 2
Mario - 2
Sonic the Hedgehog - 1
Link - 1
Prince - 1
Guybrush Threepwood - 1
Madison Paige - 1
Ms. Pac-Man - 1
Reverend Ray - 1
Kratos - 1

Snake - 10
Toad - 10
Gordon Freeman - 2
Cloud - 2
Mario - 2
Sonic the Hedgehog - 1
Link - 1
Prince - 1
Guybrush Threepwood - 1
Madison Paige - 1
Ms. Pac-Man - 1
Reverend Ray - 1
Kratos - 1

Lack of people voting Cloud/Sephiroth leads me to believe teh remake isn't really wanted.

Might have been a good idea to define "legendary" in the OP, I feel like this is more of a "Who is teh hardcorezt!"

Snake - 10
Toad - 10
Gordon Freeman - 2
Cloud - 2
Mario - 3
Sonic the Hedgehog - 1
Link - 1
Prince - 1
Guybrush Threepwood - 1
Madison Paige - 1
Ms. Pac-Man - 1
Reverend Ray - 1
Kratos - 1

Take this as a vote for Toad.

Snake - 11
Toad - 10
Gordon Freeman - 2
Cloud - 2
Mario - 3
Sonic the Hedgehog - 1
Link - 1
Prince - 1
Guybrush Threepwood - 1
Madison Paige - 1
Ms. Pac-Man - 1
Reverend Ray - 1
Kratos - 1

Snake is teh hardcorez!

nordlead said: ^^ I screwed up the count, but toad is winning. @kasz I've also loved luigi, but not to the point where I'd be willing to kill Mario. That is just cruel

Hey, there is a reason why you can't tell if small children are going to be sociopaths when they grow up.

It's because ALL small children are sociopaths.

I don't know if you epoepl can't count but did no one notice toad and snake jump at 2-3 at a time? Officially Snake is actually at 7 and toad at 8.