By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - Valkyria Chronicles vs Lost Odyssey

Carl2291 said:
ArcticGabe said:
I guess VC is massively over tracking here... along with many games....

I just need to ask...

What makes you say that?

Well, the two reference points we have (VC launch month, VC ltd through Jan 2009) both have VGC overtracking NPD by 20-30%, which is too high a margin to count for Canada/Mexico (where VC was given a "limited" launch anyway).  We need a new NPD ltd leak to make sure though, but it's looking like VGC was overtracking it from day one.

It'd be nice if Sega gave out shipment figures too.  Maybe when VC2 gets closer to release, they might throw sales in a PR if the turnaround's as dramatic as VGC implies?



Around the Network
jarrod said:
Carl2291 said:
ArcticGabe said:
I guess VC is massively over tracking here... along with many games....

I just need to ask...

What makes you say that?

Well, the two reference points we have (VC launch month, VC ltd through Jan 2009) both have VGC overtracking NPD by 20-30%, which is too high a margin to count for Canada/Mexico (where VC was given a "limited" launch anyway).  We need a new NPD ltd leak to make sure though, but it's looking like VGC was overtracking it from day one.

It'd be nice if Sega gave out shipment figures too.  Maybe when VC2 gets closer to release, they might throw sales in a PR if the turnaround's as dramatic as VGC implies?

Or maybe... NPD undertracked...?



                            

Carl2291 said:
jarrod said:
Carl2291 said:
ArcticGabe said:
I guess VC is massively over tracking here... along with many games....

I just need to ask...

What makes you say that?

Well, the two reference points we have (VC launch month, VC ltd through Jan 2009) both have VGC overtracking NPD by 20-30%, which is too high a margin to count for Canada/Mexico (where VC was given a "limited" launch anyway).  We need a new NPD ltd leak to make sure though, but it's looking like VGC was overtracking it from day one.

It'd be nice if Sega gave out shipment figures too.  Maybe when VC2 gets closer to release, they might throw sales in a PR if the turnaround's as dramatic as VGC implies?

Or maybe... NPD undertracked...?

It's always possible.  That's why I'd like to see a more recent leak, to see if there's been any upwards adjustment.

 

Edit: looking at a few other titles, there may be something to VGC overtracking some PS games.  They have Uncharted 2 a whopping ~300k above NPD, LBP PSP by ~50k over and GT PSP and AC PSP each ~100k over!  In fact they have GT higher in week 9 than NPD has it for all of November?!  Maybe it's due to demographic swings with the retailers VGC works with or something (being more PS centric than the nation)?

Actually, it's looks like they're overtracking US PSP games by huge margins generally (over 50%) versus NPD?  What's going on?



Seeing Sega shipments would be really good.
LO was already much closer to milion but got adjusted down by a lot of copies when LTD sales were reported somewhere.



PROUD MEMBER OF THE PSP RPG FAN CLUB

The north American cover of lost oddyssey is soooo sick I'm surprised the Japanese one is so ugly.


I think Lost Odyssey will finish on top. But putting sales aside, valkyria does not even come close to lost odyssey in terms of quality.



Around the Network

i think valkyria chronicles will cross 1 million 1st, which is extremely sad and very disappointing as well. vc is a good game, but for me its not in the same league as lost odyssey. the reason is for me lost odyssey is the best rpg ever and has the best story and the dreams in the game are extremely well written. i have now beaten lost odyssey 7 times and still enjoy and love playing it each time.



GAMERTAG IS ANIMEHEAVEN X23

PSN ID IS : ANIMEREALM 

PROUD MEMBER OF THE RPG FAN CLUB THREAD

ALL-TIME FAVORITE JRPG IS : LOST ODYSSEY

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=52882&page=1

perpride said:
But putting sales aside, valkyria does not even come close to lost odyssey in terms of quality.

Yeah. Valkyria is a lot better .

Deserves hit 1 million.



perpride said:
The north American cover of lost oddyssey is soooo sick I'm surprised the Japanese one is so ugly.


I think Lost Odyssey will finish on top. But putting sales aside, valkyria does not even come close to lost odyssey in terms of quality.

LOL what is so awesome with lost odyssey??? looks like an unoriginal JRPG to me.

 



Owner of PS1/PSOne , PS2 phat/slim  , PS3 phat/slim , PS Eye+Move and PSP phat/slim/brite/go (Sony)

The Official PS Vita Thread! Get all your latest PS Vita news here! Come join us!

 


perpride said:
The north American cover of lost oddyssey is soooo sick I'm surprised the Japanese one is so ugly.


I think Lost Odyssey will finish on top. But putting sales aside, valkyria does not even come close to lost odyssey in terms of quality.

Exactly.

Lost Odyssey
= Best JRPG this gen so far (this may change with FFXIII, or maybe not)

Sakaguchi's vision,
Uematsu's music,
The thousand years dreams...

It was an awesome (and moving) experience.





     

My Gaming Setup

My top two favorite current generation games, I hope they both hit 1 million at the same time.



PSN: HobsonA

XBL: HobsonA