I'm not a game, I'm a person and as I said it's for my brother.  His birthday is in January so that's when I'll probably get the other.

Well, I don't know your brother, but both are great games, so it kind of comes down to what kind of game he likes the most.

Let me ask everyone this. What was good about the game?

Plenty of positive feedback, thaks guys.

Iv gotten a few hours into the game...the game itself is good but I just dont like the setting its in like with the whole train thing...if your a hardcore zelda fan this game might feel a little odd to you it did for me atleast I just dont think there should be trains in a zelda game or any other mechanical vehicle boats are fine but train ehh...Other then that minor complaint its a pretty good game lots of fun so far.

What's good about the game?

Cinematics are probably some of the best in the series if you ask me, its all done in game like all Zelda titles, and its hilarious at times. Not to mention some of the best graphics and style on the DS.

Then they improved the controls over Phantom Hourglass, its relatively the same but they took thins like the roll which was annoying to do in the first game and mapped it to double tap and it works great now, along with that it points at things you're targeting now so you're not randomly wondering "why am I running at that thing?" cause you didn't mean to tap it.

It continues the WW story, its set about 100 years after PH, so you'll get a bit more of that story.

It changes up the puzzles a lot, it really seems like Zelda but you're not going to see repeat puzzles and they might boggle your mind for a second. With that the game is harder than recent games because it is taking away a bit of that familiarity.

Also, BEST USE OF ZELDA INSTRUMENTS EVAR! Using the pan flute and blowing into the mic is awesome and feels natural. Who knew blowing into a mic could immerse you more into the game...

Yeah... by taking it out :P

IMO it has the best graphics on the DS. The game is just beautiful.

Also, my brother operates a real steam engine train and he had a blast putting english on the whistle.

Holy crap, i didn't even notice the lack of WiFi Connection logo on there.

Amazingly good.. its hard to put down.. the exact opposite of Phantom Hourglass.