WOW....I know it will get B-slapped by Mass Effect 2 in terms of gameplay, but not even being nominated is highway robbery. Personally I think the game looks great and is becoming more underrated than I once thought. Halo Reach, Heavy Rain, FFXIII Versus and Splinter Cell: Conviction weren't even added! WTF Spike!?
Nominees:
Bioshock 2
God of War 3
Mass Effect 2
StarCraft 2
http://www.gametrailers.com/event/vga/vote/34776