The Liberty City in GTA 3 was okay, Vice City was pretty cool. It had alot of character too it, it felt 80's and it just looked right. San Andreas was also good and it had fantastic scale. I would have to say Vice City is my fave and a return to Vice City would be amazing.

San Andreas.

I actually heard that as a rumour to what was happening in GTA 4 ages ago. I would like it to come true in a future gta.

Please a diffrent city AND
as these where PS2 games it shouldnt be in the XBOX section (actually vice city and san where ported to xbox later so shut me up)
BUT! it will be on 360 & PS3 so you would get more responces if you put in general gaming mate

Why in M$ section?

Anyway, why I didn't really like Liberty City, the rest are pretty much tied.
I loved the atmosphere in VC, and spent loads of time there in VC and VCS. The key about SA was its variety and the sheer number of things to do. IV's key was the size and detail of the city, and I just love the NYC setting and having it more life like makes the city more vibrant

However, what I would really love is some of VC and some of SA

oh and shouldn't this be in gaming as i seriously doubt that GTA5 will be xbox exclusive

San Andreas. I loved going to the casinos, then going to the country side, then going back the hood to take care of business

Vice City!

I played so much of it I can play the game without a map now.

Vice City was my favorite game, but San Andreas was probably my favorite location.  I didn't really like any of the cities as much as Vice/Liberty City, but the whole package, especially the countryside, was great.

But not on one map right? O.o That'll be a quick plane ride from NYC, Miami, and to the entire state of California.