I'm only saying it's flawed since, most of the 7's that edge gave, i enjoyed much more than 10's. So I'm going by my previous experience here.

Thats bull**** Edge have allways scored the main super mario games ULTRAHIGH(between 9 and 10) - so there must be a damned good reason for them to only score NSMBW a 7

Now im worried

There's no online multiplayer, go figure.

This thread's going slower than expected. Had the OP changed the title to "Edge Scores: NSMBWii = 7, Uncharted 2 = 9" we'd be on page 8 by now.

Edge score titles based on a 1-10 scale, unlike the 6-10 scale most reviewers seem to use.

In other words, the score for NSMBWii is fine. They don't think it's spectacular, but they think it's great fun. And that's a 7. Edge always have and always will review games like this. Get used to it.

Well its first review of Marios so we can't judge edge yet..
Kingdom Hearts has got those 8-6 reviews much so 5 ain't that huge (tho its bad).
Tekken 6 has got those 90+ so 7 kinda hurts.

Nope Official Nintendo magazine gave it 9.6

Ouch for Borderland =(

Operation Flashpoint also got a higher score than I assumed

Nope official Nintendo magazine gave it 96%

No Edge is the second review for NSMB Wii it got a 9.6 on the first review.