By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - IGN's review of Magnacarta 2 is an utter joke

I played it, It's a horrible game. It's slightly worse than Star Ocean 4, and that was a travesty on the jrpg genre.

The review is valid. Do I need to post a picture of me playing it? It's my opinion, which is what a review is, and what this thread is about.

Unless you were not talking to me.



Around the Network
inverted3reality said:
I played it, It's a horrible game. It's slightly worse than Star Ocean 4, and that was a travesty on the jrpg genre.

The review is valid. Do I need to post a picture of me playing it? It's my opinion, which is what a review is, and what this thread is about.

Unless you were not talking to me.

I was referring to A Bad Clown who said that, the game is not on his gamercard, so I'm assuming he hasn't played it.



themanwithnoname's law: As an America's sales or NPD thread grows longer, the probabilty of the comment "America = World" [sarcasticly] being made approaches 1.

themanwithnoname said:
inverted3reality said:
I played it, It's a horrible game. It's slightly worse than Star Ocean 4, and that was a travesty on the jrpg genre.

The review is valid. Do I need to post a picture of me playing it? It's my opinion, which is what a review is, and what this thread is about.

Unless you were not talking to me.

I was referring to A Bad Clown who said that, the game is not on his gamercard, so I'm assuming he hasn't played it.

my appologise, I was incredibly rude there for basically no reason what so ever.




That part about lack of japanise voices is funny :)



PROUD MEMBER OF THE PSP RPG FAN CLUB

inverted3reality said:
themanwithnoname said:
inverted3reality said:
I played it, It's a horrible game. It's slightly worse than Star Ocean 4, and that was a travesty on the jrpg genre.

The review is valid. Do I need to post a picture of me playing it? It's my opinion, which is what a review is, and what this thread is about.

Unless you were not talking to me.

I was referring to A Bad Clown who said that, the game is not on his gamercard, so I'm assuming he hasn't played it.

my appologise, I was incredibly rude there for basically no reason what so ever.


No worries dude, in fairness, he might've played the game, if that's the case, I retract my statement. Sorry you didn't like it much though.



themanwithnoname's law: As an America's sales or NPD thread grows longer, the probabilty of the comment "America = World" [sarcasticly] being made approaches 1.

Around the Network
inverted3reality said:
themanwithnoname said:
inverted3reality said:
I played it, It's a horrible game. It's slightly worse than Star Ocean 4, and that was a travesty on the jrpg genre.

The review is valid. Do I need to post a picture of me playing it? It's my opinion, which is what a review is, and what this thread is about.

Unless you were not talking to me.

I was referring to A Bad Clown who said that, the game is not on his gamercard, so I'm assuming he hasn't played it.

my appologise, I was incredibly rude there for basically no reason what so ever.



Your usually rude regardless, reason or not...there was no need to go as far as posting a picture of your (or whoever elses') 360, or carrying on an argument with yourself (seeing as how "themanwithnoname" wasn't reffering to you in the first place).



Follow Me: twitter.com/alkamiststar

Watch Me: youtube.com/alkamiststar

Play Along: XBL & SEN : AlkamistStar

the 1st game was utter shit. did you guys really expect the 2nd one to be significantly better? wait, did you even play the 1st game?



inverted3reality said:
Barozi said:
A Bad Clown said:
He didn't like it! Why do you care? If you like playing mediocre games to spend your time go buy it.

Metacritic disagrees with you

a... no it doesnt. under 80 = mediocre. under 70 = total shit. under 75 = pretty horrible.

I pray this is a joke. I really do.



"We'll toss the dice however they fall,
And snuggle the girls be they short or tall,
Then follow young Mat whenever he calls,
To dance with Jak o' the Shadows."

Check out MyAnimeList and my Game Collection. Owner of the 5 millionth post.

AlkamistStar said:
inverted3reality said:
themanwithnoname said:
inverted3reality said:
I played it, It's a horrible game. It's slightly worse than Star Ocean 4, and that was a travesty on the jrpg genre.

The review is valid. Do I need to post a picture of me playing it? It's my opinion, which is what a review is, and what this thread is about.

Unless you were not talking to me.

I was referring to A Bad Clown who said that, the game is not on his gamercard, so I'm assuming he hasn't played it.

my appologise, I was incredibly rude there for basically no reason what so ever.



Your usually rude regardless, reason or not...there was no need to go as far as posting a picture of your (or whoever elses') 360, or carrying on an argument with yourself (seeing as how "themanwithnoname" wasn't reffering to you in the first place).

Someone stated I never had one, which was the first rude statement to make.

I Post a picture and wrote my name on a piece of paper to prove it.

The game isn't good, I am entitled to my opinion.

@outlawauron

In the past, games under and around 75 were awesome. But now adays reviews are skewed. Pretty much anything under 70 is what would get 0-20 in the past. Around 70 is the realm of shovelware, i mean seriously, go look at metacritic.

I dont agree with it, i feel 70 should be good, but it just USUALLY (not always) Isn't.

 

and people are missing up what mediocre means.

 

. of only ordinary or moderate quality; neither good nor bad; barely adequate.



A Bad Clown said:
He didn't like it! Why do you care? If you like playing mediocre games to spend your time go buy it.

I care because reviews like this prevents people from picking up a quality game.  And I dont play medicore games, I just have better tastes in games that you do.