By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - EDGE reviews Demon's Souls ! Oh the suspence....

9/10

OMGWTFBBQ !

http://www.edge-online.com/magazine/review-demons-souls



Around the Network

Can we please lay to rest the accusations that Edge is biased?



dsister44 said:
Can we please lay to rest the accusations that Edge is biased?

These sites are only "biased" when they don't like a certain game and rate it accordingly (MGS4, R2 and others) or they rate halo 3 a perfect(Obviously 360 bias right). Also they gave LBP a 10, it seems that won't be remembered at all.



 

I don't think "bias" was ever the right word to use for Edge review scores. They tend to lack a cohesive scoring system, or at least a logical one.



The main question on this site has been "what did they give Uncharted 2" for the past few weeks :)



Around the Network

LBP is british, british = marks on edge
Halo, WRPGs = marks on edge
360 exclusives = marks on edge

Anything else (except VERY few titles) = not so much marks on edge
This review must have being wrote when they were not drunk.
I will consider them unbiased the day Uncharted 2 recieves a 9 or higher that it deserves.



I now officially like EDGE. :P



4 ≈ One

I dont think Edge is biased. I'd say a bit harsh:P
btw did they reviewed Uncharted? :D



Scoobes said:
I don't think "bias" was ever the right word to use for Edge review scores. They tend to lack a cohesive scoring system, or at least a logical one.

Its a bit of both actually.



MetalGearSolid_4ever said:
Scoobes said:
I don't think "bias" was ever the right word to use for Edge review scores. They tend to lack a cohesive scoring system, or at least a logical one.

Its a bit of both actually.

They just suck a reviewing games, looking at 7/10 for Valkyria Chronicles with anger.