Edge gave Demon's Souls a 9. :O

Isn't LBP the only other ps3 exclusive that got a 9+ from them?

Edit:

Yup.  Other Edge review scores:

LittleBigPlanet - 10
Metal Gear Solid 4 - 8
Uncharted - 8
Killzone 2 - 7

@ocnkng

you said it all dude. A good review is a good review no matter the score. When you throw grades to the air and write little and vaguely to back it up, that says one thing or two about your integrity.

^that was not a GOOD write up, and excuse me, but ocnkng is right. So am I.

^nope. I'll teach you one trick I learned a long time ago from this videogame media circus aka reviews and metascore :


Next time you look at a Metascore , think of this:

WHEN NO ONE DARES TO GIVE A "100" TO A GAME, QUESTION ITS "90s".


QFT.

They gave one of the MP games less than an 8!?

EDGE is one of the craziest reviewers ever.

^ Edge is not like every other reviewer.

For them, 5 = average. Anything above a 5 is above average, anything below... well you get the idea. Compare this to other reviewers who will review virtually every game in the 6-10 range. I'm afriad comparing this to the 9's and 10's given out by other reviewers isn't much use.

Though i'd argue as always that the actual review is far more useful than the score.

How is this from the Nov issue... shouldn't this be October?

I pretty much agree with all the review scores across the board, there's nothing really out of the ordinary here.

Of course Edge Magazine is all about innovation:

Patapon: 8 - The level of personality in the Patapons and their world makes up for any disappointments - and your involvement in their story becomes huge.

Patapon 2: 5 - An extremely unambitious sequel.

wait.....

^HAHAHHAHA!!!! LOL ROTFL... such journalists!

WTHHH

How did that stuffed mammal get more than Snake?!