By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Can Forza 3 beat GT5 on Metacritic?

libellule on 06 September 2009
kiefer23 said:
inverted3reality said:
what do you mean nojustno? The video looks nothing like the screenshots. It looks like a completely different game. GT5 has significantly better lighting, textures, models, shadows, surprisingly better anti-aliasing(look at the trees in the F3 video, they are very jaggy).

These games are not even on the same level in terms of graphics, it's a complete landslide.
Game play however, we have no idea! So let's wait and see. I have both pre-ordered and I can't wait.


You are baseing your opinion on off-screen Youtube compressed video? Moron...

Both Forza 2 and GT4 look like utter crap compared to FM3 Stop letting Nostalgia fool you.

Heres a Sony Bullshot of GT4 back in the day.

Yeah the enviroments look so much better... and this is even a bullshot.

And the 60FPS LE Mans video is a very early build of Forza Motorsport 3.

is it his fault that the OP took a really bad/old video ?

 

(.... I was warmed because of u slimbeast lolll)



Time to Work !

Around the Network
daiyumn on 06 September 2009

damn they both look awesome



I am a loyal SONY fan and will always be.

I am also a PS1, PS2, PS3 and a PSP owner.

<a href="http://ps3trophycard.com/profile/daiyumn316"><imgsrc="http://card.mmos.com/psn/profile/da/i/daiyumn316/card.png" border="0" alt="daiyumn316 /></a>

Click this ----->  http://vgchartz.com/forum/thread.php?id=83696to post your top 10 games.

SlipperyMooseCakes on 06 September 2009

Well GTAIV scored high because of brand recognition but most people don't like the game. That just goes to show the power of brand recognition.

It's hard to tell because MC can be really unreliable. Take Fight Night Round 4 for example. PSM scored it 100% (or at least meta interpreted it that way) and the highest rating for a 360 mag was like 80 something when clearly both the games are pretty identical. Not a 20 point difference in quality/gameplay/graphics/etc. One review can sway it all. A lot of games sit at 89 and not 90 because of 1 random site review.



PSN: SlipperyMooseNG   XBL: SlipperyMooseNG

Heavenly_King on 06 September 2009

GT5 will have better rating, sales and graphics



Open World-Survival-Game Days Gone

selnor on 06 September 2009
Grey21 said:
They both look like 9.0 to 10.0 games so it's going to matter little which one comes out on top(especially since they aren't competing with each other). It's probably going to be GT5 though, if it deserves that or not I can't say (yet) but many reviewers probably grew up with GT1 and will look past any possible flaws to give it that 10/10 rating they feel it deserves.


Well GT4 released the same year as Forza 1. It was the first time GT had competition on consoles at what it does. Forza 1 actually had a meta of 92. While GT4 got meta of 89. Many reviewers said GT4 was the best GT yet, but it was rated down because there was competition adding things like online play and extensive modding.

And although GT5 has more cars than Forza 3. Forza 3 has 20+ more tracks than GT5 and in terms of features has stuff that GT5 doesn't. Like HD video editor. Fully customisable paintwork and aerofoils. We stil yet need to know whether GT5 will feature full tyre deformation as well as pitstops and fuel weights. And we are yet to see any Forza 3 gameplay with full realistic damage and fuel and tyre wear all on max realistic settings.

So all in all this is still to early to tell. But as for features so far Forza 3 has a reasonable edge. Apart from how many cars. So we will see.



Around the Network
inverted3reality on 06 September 2009
selnor said:
Grey21 said:
They both look like 9.0 to 10.0 games so it's going to matter little which one comes out on top(especially since they aren't competing with each other). It's probably going to be GT5 though, if it deserves that or not I can't say (yet) but many reviewers probably grew up with GT1 and will look past any possible flaws to give it that 10/10 rating they feel it deserves.


Well GT4 released the same year as Forza 1. It was the first time GT had competition on consoles at what it does. Forza 1 actually had a meta of 92. While GT4 got meta of 89. Many reviewers said GT4 was the best GT yet, but it was rated down because there was competition adding things like online play and extensive modding.

And although GT5 has more cars than Forza 3. Forza 3 has 20+ more tracks than GT5 and in terms of features has stuff that GT5 doesn't. Like HD video editor. Fully customisable paintwork and aerofoils. We stil yet need to know whether GT5 will feature full tyre deformation as well as pitstops and fuel weights. And we are yet to see any Forza 3 gameplay with full realistic damage and fuel and tyre wear all on max realistic settings.

So all in all this is still to early to tell. But as for features so far Forza 3 has a reasonable edge. Apart from how many cars. So we will see.

Forza 3 is lacking in pretty much every single category, how does it have more features? painting my car does not make the game better.



darthdevidem01 on 06 September 2009
inverted3reality said:
selnor said:
Grey21 said:
They both look like 9.0 to 10.0 games so it's going to matter little which one comes out on top(especially since they aren't competing with each other). It's probably going to be GT5 though, if it deserves that or not I can't say (yet) but many reviewers probably grew up with GT1 and will look past any possible flaws to give it that 10/10 rating they feel it deserves.


Well GT4 released the same year as Forza 1. It was the first time GT had competition on consoles at what it does. Forza 1 actually had a meta of 92. While GT4 got meta of 89. Many reviewers said GT4 was the best GT yet, but it was rated down because there was competition adding things like online play and extensive modding.

And although GT5 has more cars than Forza 3. Forza 3 has 20+ more tracks than GT5 and in terms of features has stuff that GT5 doesn't. Like HD video editor. Fully customisable paintwork and aerofoils. We stil yet need to know whether GT5 will feature full tyre deformation as well as pitstops and fuel weights. And we are yet to see any Forza 3 gameplay with full realistic damage and fuel and tyre wear all on max realistic settings.

So all in all this is still to early to tell. But as for features so far Forza 3 has a reasonable edge. Apart from how many cars. So we will see.

Forza 3 is lacking in pretty much every single category, how does it have more features? painting my car does not make the game better.


This is the limit....

I was ok with people insulting GT for not having proper damage.......but insulting GT because you can't paint your damn car {sigh}

 



All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey

Carl on 06 September 2009
selnor said:
Grey21 said:
They both look like 9.0 to 10.0 games so it's going to matter little which one comes out on top(especially since they aren't competing with each other). It's probably going to be GT5 though, if it deserves that or not I can't say (yet) but many reviewers probably grew up with GT1 and will look past any possible flaws to give it that 10/10 rating they feel it deserves.


Well GT4 released the same year as Forza 1. It was the first time GT had competition on consoles at what it does. Forza 1 actually had a meta of 92. While GT4 got meta of 89. Many reviewers said GT4 was the best GT yet, but it was rated down because there was competition adding things like online play and extensive modding.

And although GT5 has more cars than Forza 3. Forza 3 has 20+ more tracks than GT5 and in terms of features has stuff that GT5 doesn't. Like HD video editor. Fully customisable paintwork and aerofoils. We stil yet need to know whether GT5 will feature full tyre deformation as well as pitstops and fuel weights. And we are yet to see any Forza 3 gameplay with full realistic damage and fuel and tyre wear all on max realistic settings.

So all in all this is still to early to tell. But as for features so far Forza 3 has a reasonable edge. Apart from how many cars. So we will see.

"Features"?

Youtube replay upload. Top Gear stuff. GT TV. WRC. NASCAR. Car Washes + Oil changes. Day + Night races. Weather cycles. PS Eye functions? And plenty more to be revealed...

As for the tracks... do we know how many GT5 will have on release yet?



                            

darthdevidem01 on 06 September 2009

@carl

silent you Ps3 Advocate

You can't paint your car in GT5!!!!!



All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey

Carl on 06 September 2009
darthdevidem01 said:
@carl

silent you Ps3 Advocate

You can't paint your car in GT5!!!!!

I know. Deal breaker right there.

Who wants Rally, Weather, Day/Night cycles... when we COULD have teh paint.