insomniac hasn't posted yet, right? If so, could you PM him to see if he's participating, Gnizmo?
insomniac hasn't posted yet, right? If so, could you PM him to see if he's participating, Gnizmo?
I already have Soleron. I am waiting to see how this "day" plays out before doing more.
Votes ( Removed | Killed )
Person | Voting To Remove |
Identity | |||
Day 1 |
Day 2 | Day 3 | Day 4 | ||
zexen_lowe | That Guy | Words of Wisdom |
|||
Soleron | That Guy | ||||
Onyxmeth | That Guy | --- | --- | --- | Townsfolk |
That Guy | Onyxmeth | --- | --- | --- | Mafia |
Words Of Wisdom | Onyxmeth | Townsfolk | |||
Craan | Onyxmeth | ||||
insomniac17 | --- |
||||
RCTjunkie | --- |
--- | --- | --- |
Cop |
c03n3nj0 | --- |
Soleron said: insomniac hasn't posted yet, right? If so, could you PM him to see if he's participating, Gnizmo? |
I'm still here! Sorry! I just started college and I've been really busy lately...
Let's see... 2 mafia and 4 townsfolk.
If we remove 1 townsfolk on this game day, the mafia wins. They'll kill someone during the night putting it 2 to 2 and the towsfolk won't be able to out-vote them. So basically, if I get voted out... the mafia wins.
I'll vote for myself then. Putting 3 mafia versus 6 townsfolk is retarded and totally hoses the townsfolk. The sooner we end this game, the sooner we can start a better one that won't be run so stupidly.
Person | Voting To Remove ( Removed | Killed ) | Identity | |||
Day 1 |
Day 2 | Day 3 | Day 4 | ||
zexen_lowe | That Guy | Words Of Wisdom |
|||
Soleron | That Guy | ||||
Onyxmeth | That Guy | --- | --- | --- | Townsfolk |
That Guy | Onyxmeth | --- | --- | --- | Mafia |
Words Of Wisdom | Onyxmeth | Words Of Wisdom |
Townsfolk | ||
Craan | Onyxmeth | ||||
insomniac17 | --- |
||||
RCTjunkie | --- |
--- | --- | --- |
Cop |
c03n3nj0 | --- |
I'm confused about your chart WoW. You put yourself as town, and you voted for yourself?
Soleron said: I'm confused about your chart WoW. You put yourself as town, and you voted for yourself? |
Yep. If we remove 1 more townsfolk, the mafia wins. By removing myself, I'm basically ending the game.
Words Of Wisdom said: Let's see... 2 mafia and 4 townsfolk. If we remove 1 townsfolk on this game day, the mafia wins. They'll kill someone during the night putting it 2 to 2 and the towsfolk won't be able to out-vote them. So basically, if I get voted out... the mafia wins. I'll vote for myself then. Putting 3 mafia versus 6 townsfolk is retarded and totally hoses the townsfolk. The sooner we end this game, the sooner we can start a better one that won't be run so stupidly. |
I will respect your decision, and openly admit I am not terribly experienced in running these games. Typically speaking I share your reservation towards having such a high number of mafia to such a low number of townsfolk. At the same time the original setting (which I copied and pasted) called for 3 mafia, and 7 townsfolk. This gives the mafia a remarkably similar power in voting when compared to 3 vs 6 (30% vs 33%). 2 vs 7 would have slanted it much further away (22%) from that original ratio that I was trying to maintain. While I respect your decision to drop out, I would like to point out that the time to voice such objections would have been before the game started. I do not defend this as the right move overall, but given the original numbers I stand behind it being the best way to maintain the ratio balance outlined.
Rereading the posts more, I have completely convinced myself that Craan is mafia, while WoW might be (I think she is) but it's better to go for the sure thing.
I have given pretty good reasons for TG being mafia, and he seemed too sure that he wasn't
"except That Guy is almost certainly not a mafia "
"I would rather lynch someone that had a possibility of being a mafia than lynch someone that has little to no chance of being one"
"voting for Onyx is safer in that it is more likely that he is a mafia."
Unvote - WoW
Vote - Craan