By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - GT5 have fake damage system.

mibuokami said:
Carl2291 said:
waron said:
haxxiy said:
Not trying to sound like a fanboy or anything, but someone with knowledge in Physics could calculate how much weight a car suspension holds and the strength of the impacts shown in the video, so we could have a rough idea if the handling should be affected in some way or not?

that bumper should affect car alone, basically it should fall off after a while.

@Munkeh111, that's what i'm saying if it's not in all the cars then don't release info in fact sheet that there is damage in all cars when there isn't.

All cars have damage, a premium set of cars have exterior AND interior damage.

Now i say it again... please... Shut up waron.

From IGN:

First off, Kazunori confirmed that not all the cars in Gran Turismo 5 will have damage models -- only select sets of cars will feature damage support. No official word yet on what those car sets are, but hopefully we'll have more on that soon.

Unless IGN got the translation wrong (which is a possibility although not high as they've mentioned this in 2 article now), then this is a big fail imo. You can't have a game where car deformation only exist for certain car so in the end when you pick cars to race, you will only be able to pick from the deformation set , the non-defomration set or turn damage off.

However else you want to justify the fact that PD are artist and perfectionist, they are also still entertainers and to me, the above is something that should be highly criticised as its simply not good enough.

They interviewed the translator!



                            

Around the Network
FilaBrasileiro said:
waron said:

so to all those people that scream "GT5 have real damage system" i would like to point out two simple things you can clearly see from those videos:

1. damage don't affect handling AT ALL, WRONG. People who PLAYED the game there said that there is mechanical damage.

2. there's no car deformation AT ALL. cars are hitting walls and we can see no deformation on bumpers and front of the cars eventhoug the bumper is half on the street. car hit the wall sideway and doors are fapping all the way but still not a single scratch on them, WRONG. Again peole at the event have said that doors fell off and cars were deformed, as well as paints coming off and scratches.

 

THAT'S NOT DAMAGE SYSTEM.

when car in Forza 3 drive into sand we can even see dirt on the front, we can see scratches when it hits wall, we can see deformation when it will hit the wall. GT5 on those Gamescon videos have non of those.

Add to that that they were only demoeing Arcade mode at the event.


waron should change is name to wrong instead.

^door falls off as does bumper fly upwards, looks amazing



...not much time to post anymore, used to be awesome on here really good fond memories from VGchartz...

PSN: Skeeuk - XBL: SkeeUK - PC: Skeeuk

really miss the VGCHARTZ of 2008 - 2013...

im happy it doesnt make it harder....then i would suck



im happy it doesnt make it harder....then i would suck



kowenicki said:
@carl

I just think news stories should be neutral, factual and not too subjective. Thats for reviews. I may be wrong.

and you are being pedantic on the damage thing... read my post and i said we dont know either way, but IF it is purely cosmetic then its a joke.

Neutral? How can i make it neutral when its a news story about Gran Turismo 5? What do you want me to do... talk about Forza 3? (Im not sure i get what you mean on this)

Factual... the article is factual, i wrote nothing "false".

Subjective, i suppose thats just my writing style im afraid. If im excited about something im going to hype it up as much as possible. If i think something deserves praise... it gets praise.

I apologise for being pedantic, i admit i was an ass



                            

Around the Network

This thread is really funny xD

Neither side is making any sense



I already suck at GT games, I don't need damages making me crapper, I hope to God this damage is optional it might kill the entire thing for me :(



PS One/2/p/3slim/Vita owner. I survived the Apocalyps3/Collaps3 and all I got was this lousy signature.


Xbox One: What are you doing Dave?

--OkeyDokey-- said:
Forza 3 has fake damage too.

Games = not real.

Don't feed me that bullshit!!!  Games are real man!!!

*Goes and crys in corner while holding his copy of Halo 3*



WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG..........wrong.

Someone was at Gamecom and played the game. He said that after a few crashes the vehicle it slowed down and only went up to forth gear. So not only did it have exterior damage it also has interior damage which affected the vehicle. On top of that this was just arcade mode so we have yet to see the career mode which is where the real physics show.

OP I know you have some problem with the PS3 for a sad reason but don't bring Gran Turismo 5 into your bullshit.



 

You guys bitch about everything. Who here has played GT5 and Forza 3? /thread



GamerTag/PSN ID JoshmyersBV (please add me I have 2 friends on Xbox Live)