Valkyria most certainly is NOT overrated its still going strong.

Why is BioShock overrated? I hear its a great game from everyone!

Left 4 Dead

CS:S

Halo 3

every single ps3 exclusive

i dont like em either.

i like class based ones though.

Bioshock, Ocarina of Time, Starcraft.

Bioshock............. that is all.

There are so many overrated games.

OoT (any zelda game actually)
SMG
GTA IV
Metroid prime
Super mario 64
Half-life
Chrono Trigger
Perfect Dark
Goldeneye 007
Okami
Persona 4
Wave Race 64
Viewtiful Joe
Final Fantasy XII

Those got way too high reviews.

GTAIV

People saying Zelda or Mario -1 respect

Valkyrie is lifted to sky high on this site. I watched it on Playme (or what that play-through site is called) and it looked like a sub 80% game.

Bioshock is awesome, but not worthy of 95% it has on Metacritic. Although it's certainly not getting the praise it deserves here on VGC, because this site is strangely enough filled with JRPG-lovers.

GTA IV.
its got perfect scores just for the name.
and it did alot less than San Andreas.

FFVII
People like this game because its the first Final Fantasy they played, but they worship it to infinity , its not that good, and its not the best FF out there.

Halo 3
this isn't the best Halo out there, and its not the best shooter either.

Call Of Duty 4
this game is okay-ish , it borrows scenes from movies which makes it too cliche , and expected, the gameplay is very easy , and it was made for newcomers , i don't know how that would be a good thing for FPS fans.

Assassins Creed
This game is crappy plain and simple.

Crysis
this game is just graphics, its very boring in everything else.

Street Fighter
an unbalanced fighting game is NEVER the best, seriously, its really all about fireballs and the game is just generic, if you remove the internet goggles off.