I'll never get why people ask for the last two. The 1-on-1 will not work unless they totally revamp the gameplay. You have all of 4 punches, it is like going back to Atari 2600 boxing. Also, online is useless unless the vs. mode is compelling which it isn't and can't really be.

Well, the 1 on 1 mode felt kind of slow. And the only well.... be able to choose more than one character in fight with people from all over the world... i like that idea.

Absolutely, first one was fantastic. And like a few others in the thread have pointed out, I wouldn't call the sales "poor".

Poor sales? It will break 750k this year.

Maybe this time we'll get to take on Princess Peach.

Next Level Games have proven themselves and I would let them do that if that's what they want. However I'd like to see them given a bit more room to grow and maybe try a new sports IP for themselves.

I'd love it if they made another Punch-Out!! with more fighter from Super Punch Out!! and many new ones.

They did an awesome job with Punch-Out!!, they managed to make it feel like it's own game even though they mostly took fighters from the first game. Title Defense mode is a brillant addition, the challenges also keep you coming back to the game.

Hell yes.

I loved the humor they had in the last one.

it is a good game - i tried it, but damn for 50$ you can finish most of the challenges and modes in 2-3 days and multiplayer is fun for first 10 minutes. while it's a very good game it is good only for less than 20$.
Punch Out WII 2:
more characters,
online,
1 on 1 with DIFFERENT characters,
some kind of story mode or somethin for every fighter even something like Sunday vs Magazine would be ok where you have 9 fights and the final fight is always new character that you will unlock if you win the fight,
unlockable move sets,
unlockable swag like stats and history of each fighter, nes/snes original game, galleries, music, movies etc.