By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - Uncharted 2 vs Halo 3:ODST

tedsteriscool on 08 July 2009
selnor said:
tedsteriscool said:
selnor said:
tedsteriscool said:
selnor said:
The said:
tedsteriscool said:
Halo will sell more, Uncharted 2 will be the better game.


/thread


Your opinion. I can think of nearly 10 million people that disagree. I'm one. Halo 3 was far the better game. /Thread.

Wow Selnor I thought with all of the Sony bashing over the past 2 years that you'd never get a PS3, let alone with Uncharted. And you must have beaten Uncharted if you're able to make conclusions about it so quickly, am I right?


Dude I finished Uncharted nearly a year ago. I forgot people have to own a console this gen to actually play the games. I have 2 friends with PS3's. ( Likely not for long though ). I have also nearly finished MGS4 ( but that game requires serious dedication for all the cutscenes, even as someone who's finished the previous 3 ). Also played GT5P extensively online, and more recently finished half of KZ2, whilst watching the other half ( no coop, so we had to do the whole in turn thing. )

I have a friend with a 360 and I played Halo 3 and it sucked!

 

...Really now, is my claim any less credible than yours?

No it isn't less credible. It's absolutely fine actually. The small difference is I didnt say Uncharted sucks, and I kinda have nearly 10 million Halo 3 people on my wavelength. And it still sells weekly more than KZ2. Which says alot.

No but you implied that PS3 sucks and that your friends will likely get rid of them in the future. My point is stop being so conclusive without concrete evidence. A picture of you playing Uncharted on a PS3 would suffice



Around the Network
XxXProphecyXxX on 08 July 2009
kowenicki said:
@prophecy

You can certainly say you didnt like Halo3. To say it was crap is fanboy talk.

sry if It was harsh won't do it again just my opinion hope wer cool.



Asmo on 08 July 2009
selnor said:

 I kinda have nearly 10 million Halo 3 people on my wavelength. And it still sells weekly more than KZ2. Which says alot.

Wii Sports, Wii Play and Wii Fit best games ever, confirmed?



selnor on 08 July 2009
tedsteriscool said:
selnor said:
tedsteriscool said:
selnor said:
tedsteriscool said:
selnor said:
The said:
tedsteriscool said:
Halo will sell more, Uncharted 2 will be the better game.


/thread


Your opinion. I can think of nearly 10 million people that disagree. I'm one. Halo 3 was far the better game. /Thread.

Wow Selnor I thought with all of the Sony bashing over the past 2 years that you'd never get a PS3, let alone with Uncharted. And you must have beaten Uncharted if you're able to make conclusions about it so quickly, am I right?


Dude I finished Uncharted nearly a year ago. I forgot people have to own a console this gen to actually play the games. I have 2 friends with PS3's. ( Likely not for long though ). I have also nearly finished MGS4 ( but that game requires serious dedication for all the cutscenes, even as someone who's finished the previous 3 ). Also played GT5P extensively online, and more recently finished half of KZ2, whilst watching the other half ( no coop, so we had to do the whole in turn thing. )

I have a friend with a 360 and I played Halo 3 and it sucked!

 

...Really now, is my claim any less credible than yours?

No it isn't less credible. It's absolutely fine actually. The small difference is I didnt say Uncharted sucks, and I kinda have nearly 10 million Halo 3 people on my wavelength. And it still sells weekly more than KZ2. Which says alot.

No but you implied that PS3 sucks and that your friends will likely get rid of them in the future. My point is stop being so conclusive without concrete evidence. A picture of you playing Uncharted on a PS3 would suffice

Next time I'm there I will take some photo's of me playing a few games. A video even. :)

It's not that the PS3 is all suckful, but I live in the UK. PS3 doesn't have great love here. Like I mentioned in another thread, 360 is about to be double PS3 userbase here, and about to overtake wii at this rate. We hardly play PS3 when like 10 of us get together. The guys who own PS3's I know, are thinking of selling to buy all the 360 games out this year, and the new Forza 3 wheel. So it's pretty likely I may not know anyone with a PS3. IT's sad bu GC was in a similar position last gen here in UK. Although I had a GC purely becasue up until half way through last gen I was a massive GC fanboy, that turned into massive PS2 fanboy.



gtcarro on 08 July 2009
Asmo said:
selnor said:
 

 I kinda have nearly 10 million Halo 3 people on my wavelength. And it still sells weekly more than KZ2. Which says alot.

Wii Sports, Wii Play and Wii Fit best games ever, confirmed?


Touché.

And comparing halo3 to Killzone 2 is like comparing a Fiat (halo3) to a Ferrari (KZ2).



Uncharted & The Last of Us 

(Definitely, best games of last Gen)

Around the Network
selnor on 08 July 2009
gtcarro said:
Asmo said:
selnor said:
 

 I kinda have nearly 10 million Halo 3 people on my wavelength. And it still sells weekly more than KZ2. Which says alot.

Wii Sports, Wii Play and Wii Fit best games ever, confirmed?


Touché.

And comparing halo3 to Killzone 2 is like comparing a Fiat (halo3) to a Ferrari (KZ2).


Well Wii sports is given with every Wii. So noone buys it out of choice. Wii fit though. Yes. To the people that keep buying it may just be the best game. Why is it hard to believe a casual gamer would like it. It makes sense.

Seriously your Fiat Ferrari comparison. LOL.

KZ2 to many many people is the fiat mate. not the ferrari.



Tony_Parker on 08 July 2009

Well let's see...

Halo 3 ODST is an expansion pack to a 2006 game which was one of the all time most adverted game and probably one of the most overrated too.

Uncharted 2 is a groundbreaking full game sequel of a recent blockbuster whose demo made jaws drop with incredible graphics and hollywood like action.

So it's not even close... Uncharted 2 wins hands down.



FilaBrasileiro on 08 July 2009
selnor said:
gtcarro said:
Asmo said:
selnor said:
 

I kinda have nearly 10 million Halo 3 people on my wavelength. And it still sells weekly more than KZ2. Which says alot.

Wii Sports, Wii Play and Wii Fit best games ever, confirmed?


Touché.

And comparing halo3 to Killzone 2 is like comparing a Fiat (halo3) to a Ferrari (KZ2).


Well Wii sports is given with every Wii. So noone buys it out of choice. Wii fit though. Yes. To the people that keep buying it may just be the best game. Why is it hard to believe a casual gamer would like it. It makes sense.

Seriously your Fiat Ferrari comparison. LOL.

KZ2 to many many people is the fiat mate. not the ferrari.

 

Because WiiFit sucks major donkey balls, to suggest it's better than a game such as Uncharted or Halo 3 (even though I didn't like it and as I said before I'm not a fan of the series) is ridiculous.

It's a casual game for casual people and that's perfectly fine.

Sales does not necessarily mean better quality. Never have, never will.

Nintendogs is not a better game than Gears of War.Monster Hunter is not a better game than Shadow of the Colossus.High School Musical is not a better movie than Schindler's List.Mamma Mia is not a better movie than Pulp Fiction.

And so on and so on.

Of course there are times where sales does equal quality like TLOR is a great movie, TDK is a great movie, SMG is a great game, GT is a great game and so on.

Point is, one shouldn't say: "oh this game/movie is better because it sold more and I got X millions that I agree with me" because well that's just retarded.

 



gtcarro on 08 July 2009
selnor said:
tedsteriscool said:
selnor said:
tedsteriscool said:
selnor said:
tedsteriscool said:
selnor said:
The said:
tedsteriscool said:
Halo will sell more, Uncharted 2 will be the better game.


/thread


Your opinion. I can think of nearly 10 million people that disagree. I'm one. Halo 3 was far the better game. /Thread.

Wow Selnor I thought with all of the Sony bashing over the past 2 years that you'd never get a PS3, let alone with Uncharted. And you must have beaten Uncharted if you're able to make conclusions about it so quickly, am I right?


Dude I finished Uncharted nearly a year ago. I forgot people have to own a console this gen to actually play the games. I have 2 friends with PS3's. ( Likely not for long though ). I have also nearly finished MGS4 ( but that game requires serious dedication for all the cutscenes, even as someone who's finished the previous 3 ). Also played GT5P extensively online, and more recently finished half of KZ2, whilst watching the other half ( no coop, so we had to do the whole in turn thing. )

I have a friend with a 360 and I played Halo 3 and it sucked!

 

...Really now, is my claim any less credible than yours?

No it isn't less credible. It's absolutely fine actually. The small difference is I didnt say Uncharted sucks, and I kinda have nearly 10 million Halo 3 people on my wavelength. And it still sells weekly more than KZ2. Which says alot.

No but you implied that PS3 sucks and that your friends will likely get rid of them in the future. My point is stop being so conclusive without concrete evidence. A picture of you playing Uncharted on a PS3 would suffice

Next time I'm there I will take some photo's of me playing a few games. A video even. :)

It's not that the PS3 is all suckful, but I live in the UK. PS3 doesn't have great love here. Like I mentioned in another thread, 360 is about to be double PS3 userbase here, and about to overtake wii at this rate. We hardly play PS3 when like 10 of us get together. The guys who own PS3's I know, are thinking of selling to buy all the 360 games out this year, and the new Forza 3 wheel. So it's pretty likely I may not know anyone with a PS3. IT's sad bu GC was in a similar position last gen here in UK. Although I had a GC purely becasue up until half way through last gen I was a massive GC fanboy, that turned into massive PS2 fanboy.

Yes. UK likes to be different of Europe in everything.

Europe prefers PS3 but UK "loves" the microsoft console.

We drive on the right side of the road. You like to be different and drive in the "wrong" side.

We have €. UK likes to be different and have £

We talk about Kg you talk about pounds

I dont understand why you  talk about Km instead of miles (to be different)

But I understand you, not just because you revere the Americans but also because you are an island and islands are allways behind the main continent and in consoles you are no different.

U.S. prefer 360 too, but is a different case because microsoft is an American company and I perfectly understand why they prefer they own products instead of japonese ones.



Uncharted & The Last of Us 

(Definitely, best games of last Gen)

selnor on 08 July 2009
gtcarro said:
selnor said:
tedsteriscool said:
selnor said:
tedsteriscool said:
selnor said:
tedsteriscool said:
selnor said:
The said:
tedsteriscool said:
Halo will sell more, Uncharted 2 will be the better game.


/thread


Your opinion. I can think of nearly 10 million people that disagree. I'm one. Halo 3 was far the better game. /Thread.

Wow Selnor I thought with all of the Sony bashing over the past 2 years that you'd never get a PS3, let alone with Uncharted. And you must have beaten Uncharted if you're able to make conclusions about it so quickly, am I right?


Dude I finished Uncharted nearly a year ago. I forgot people have to own a console this gen to actually play the games. I have 2 friends with PS3's. ( Likely not for long though ). I have also nearly finished MGS4 ( but that game requires serious dedication for all the cutscenes, even as someone who's finished the previous 3 ). Also played GT5P extensively online, and more recently finished half of KZ2, whilst watching the other half ( no coop, so we had to do the whole in turn thing. )

I have a friend with a 360 and I played Halo 3 and it sucked!

 

...Really now, is my claim any less credible than yours?

No it isn't less credible. It's absolutely fine actually. The small difference is I didnt say Uncharted sucks, and I kinda have nearly 10 million Halo 3 people on my wavelength. And it still sells weekly more than KZ2. Which says alot.

No but you implied that PS3 sucks and that your friends will likely get rid of them in the future. My point is stop being so conclusive without concrete evidence. A picture of you playing Uncharted on a PS3 would suffice

Next time I'm there I will take some photo's of me playing a few games. A video even. :)

It's not that the PS3 is all suckful, but I live in the UK. PS3 doesn't have great love here. Like I mentioned in another thread, 360 is about to be double PS3 userbase here, and about to overtake wii at this rate. We hardly play PS3 when like 10 of us get together. The guys who own PS3's I know, are thinking of selling to buy all the 360 games out this year, and the new Forza 3 wheel. So it's pretty likely I may not know anyone with a PS3. IT's sad bu GC was in a similar position last gen here in UK. Although I had a GC purely becasue up until half way through last gen I was a massive GC fanboy, that turned into massive PS2 fanboy.

Yes. UK likes to be different of Europe in everything.

Europe prefers PS3 but UK "loves" the microsoft console.

We drive on the right side of the road. You like to be different and drive in the "wrong" side.

We have €. UK likes to be different and have £

We talk about Kg you talk about pounds

I dont understand why you  talk about Km instead of miles (to be different)

But I understand you, not just because you revere the Americans but also because you are an island and islands are allways behind the main continent and in consoles you are no different.

U.S. prefer 360 too, but is a different case because microsoft is an American company and I perfectly understand why they prefer they own products instead of japonese ones.

Woah!. UK is not behind Europe. We are more advnaced than most European countries. And France also is now much more 360 oriantated looking at the latest sales figures. We keep the pound because of heritage and the fact the pound is always strong. The majority of UK citizens dont want to be part of the EU. I am one of those people. I want the UK to stay the UK.

Originally, I just made a comment to show that one persons opinion is not the majority. Well it is on here because it's predominantly ventured by PS3 fans more than 360 and Wii fans. So 360 fans get outweighed on this site.