By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - Uncharted 2 vs Halo 3:ODST

@seece : sorry for making fun of you, but seriously I already explained my opinion and why Sony was doing well.

I've got nothing more to tell you. PS3 sold more than 360 from launch on the same time frame, so obviously Sony is okay right now. Any price cut would put them in front. It's already nearly profitable.

But maybe you're right and they'll die one day, we'll see, but don't bet too much on it. ;)



Around the Network
Manu_Ginobili said:
@seece : sorry for making fun of you, but seriously I already explained my opinion and why Sony was doing well.

I've got nothing more to tell you. PS3 sold more than 360 from launch on the same time frame, so obviously Sony is okay right now. Any price cut would put them in front.

But maybe you're right and they'll die one day, we'll see. ;)

Can someone ban this guy. Hes Tony_Parkers Alt acc.



@Dark_Chaos : it takes me around 45 seconds to create another account and come back with another IP among millions possibilities, so feel free to go ahead.

I'm trolling nothing, just stating facts and debating. I'm constantly under attacks by MS fanboys on the other hands. I attacked nobody but since I spoil the MS fanboy party on this site, that's me you gotta ban. Like good old nazis ? I thought freedom of speech existed in the US.

Ask yourself why you can't stand somebody disagreeing with you when he gives arguments.



Halo hands down but Uncharted 2 will be the better game.




Manu_Ginobili said:
@seece : sorry for making fun of you, but seriously I already explained my opinion and why Sony was doing well.

I've got nothing more to tell you. PS3 sold more than 360 from launch on the same time frame, so obviously Sony is okay right now. Any price cut would put them in front. It's already nearly profitable.

But maybe you're right and they'll die one day, we'll see, but don't bet too much on it. ;)

I'm not saying they're going to die, I'm saying they're not doing good. and just because the PS3 sold more from ITS launch, doesn't mean Sony are doing well.



 

Around the Network

Halo will sell more, neither will move any consoles, and both will be equally amazing games with different genres.



GOTY Contestants this year: Dead Space 2, Dark Souls, Tales of Graces f. Everything else can suck it.

Manu_Ginobili said:
@Dark_Chaos : it takes me around 45 seconds to create another account and come back with another IP among millions possibilities, so feel free to go ahead.

I'm trolling nothing, just stating facts and debating. I'm constantly under attacks by MS fanboys on the other hands. I attacked nobody but since I spoil the MS fanboy party on this site, that's me you gotta ban. Like good old nazis ? I thought freedom of speech existed in the US.

Ask yourself why you can't stand somebody disagreeing with you when he gives arguments.

Seriously, Tim_Duncan/Tony_Parker... quit making random alt accounts to troll these forums.  Mods, this is a clear admission of what he is doing.  Please permaban him, ban his IP range, and ban anyone who joins with similar talking traits and naming schemes such as Firstname_Lastname.

It is people like you, Tim/Tony/Manu, that ruin perfectly good websites like this.  Why can't you do something more constructive with your life?



selnor said:
kratos17 said:

halo will sell more but i cant see it selling consoles

uncharted will sell more consoles than odst (IMO)

WTF? Uncharted 1 barely scraped moving consoles. And even the Uncharted sales are misleading. They had bundles everywhere for the game when it was around just 1 mill. You couldnt buy a PS3 without getting a copy of Uncharted even if you didnt want it.

Uncharted 2 will be lucky to hit 2 mill, and I mean lucky without bundles. Wheras Halo 3 ODST will probably do over 5 mill without bundles.

This thread is hardly fair is it. Niether will sell consoles, but ODST will murder Uncharted 2 in sales.

Wow, even though the OP specifically said 'regardless of game sales', you still managed to turn it into a dick-measuring contest about the software. How predictable.


On topic, I expect neither to really shift gangbusters, but 360 should definitely be up for the week since, at the end of the day, ODST has Halo in the title.



Munkeh111 said:
Uncharted 2 will definitely be the better game, I thought the Uncharted SP was about 100x better than Halo 3 SP, and it brings a better campaign and co-op and online. Obviously ODST will sell better, but I don't think either will be a major console mover

So Uncharted 2 will be the better game because the first, single-player only game had a better campaign than a game almost exclusively designed around multiplayer?  I think Uncharted 2 looks amazing, but that's like comparing apples and skyscrapers.

As foor the point of this thread, neither game will probably move a huge amount of consoles, but in terms of sales, Halo will sell more in the first week than Uncharted 2 sells overall.



Shadowblind said:

Halo will sell more, neither will move any consoles, and both will be equally amazing games with different genres.


All that I'm saying is that Halo 3 moved ALOT of consoles...so it would seem to reason that Halo OSDT will do the same.  Originally, this was supposed to be an expansion type of release, but Bungie and MGS put more effort into it can are turning it into a more fleshed out game.  I expect the marketing campaign to kick off in August.



"...You can't kill ideas with a sword, and you can't sink belief structures with a broadside. You defeat them by making them change..."

- From By Schism Rent Asunder