+ Valkyria Chronicles
- Jade Empire

Valkryia Chronicles +
GTA: Libert City Stories -

This is taking forever.........

I do hope that people are only voting for/against games they have actually played

Also..are we taking any special considerations into play? For example, L4D is ok, it's fun and all but there's not really much content to it, especially when you compare to other "free-er" Valve multiplayer titles like TF2 and CS...so when I picked up L4D for 10 bucks I thought it was worth the money, but if I had bought it for 50-60 I would have been pissed.
Or..Jade Empire is fun and a really well done game, but it pales in comparison to KOTOR. So do I judge a bioware game at a higher standard than something like Peggle?

Ehhh.....

Anyway

+Psychonauts

-Jade Empire

Theres no need to over analyze its just a simple game and it usually does take a week or two to finish.

+Uncharted
-No More Heroes

+ The World Ends With You
- Doom 3 (giving the final blow to this one)

Left 4 Dead +

Doom 3 - (Eliminated)

+ Valkyria Chronicles

- Boom BLox

I think Boom Blox is gone by now.

Yeah Boom Blox is eliminated