Because it is the most awesome game ever made.... like I said, it pretty much stays at the top.... early in this gen I was considering putting Wii Sports in the No1 spot, but I never did.

I did in fact play Windwaker again this last month, still as brilliant as ever. Majora's Mask might have been higher with a little nostalgia factor, but as I only played it the first time this year I was probably too late to it's brilliance.

Not much,I do not have a top 10 list.But my favorite games are from either the Game Boy Color,Game Boy Advance or the ps2 era.Games such as "Pokemon Gold" ,"Yoshi´s Island","Guitar Hero 1&2" "Kingdom Hearts 1&2","The Legend Of Zelda the Minish Cap" "Star Wars Battlefront II".Remain as my favorite games of all time.The only two games this generation that are equally awesome,are Smash Bros Brawl and The World Ends with You.The latter which I thought it was amazing and I hope Square Enix will make a sequel of.In the case of Brawl .I probably have played it 150+ or much more.It is an extremely addictive game and the memory of me beating Boss Battles on intense up to this date, makes me smile.

Two that have done so are Tomb Raider Legend and Geo Wars. There are probably more that could but I haven't played them all yet.  I like what I played of Biohock but I didn't finish it and the same with GTA IV and Gears One.  I do plan to go back to them sometime.

I only have one silver treasure to get in TRL, before I have all the achievement points and am moving on to Tomb Raider Anniversary.  It looks like I'll have to play Geo Wars for a long time to come to get all the achievements in that one (i've only managed 30 so far), but I still think its a very fun oldschool type shooter that rivals all of the greats from the arcades of the early eighties in terms of quality.

Super Mario Galaxy, Super Smash Bros Brawl and Pokemon Platinum.

I would have guess it was perhaps your first console Zelda u played or something.

Why u thank VC for getting Mario 64 btw? If u have a N64 i mean.

No, I played OoT first, and while I did think it was amazing, you can see it is not even in my current top 10, and I rate the other Zelda's I have played better than it.

As for your second point, yes I have an N64, but I didn't buy neither SM64, nor Majora's Mask for it. (check my games page... it shows all games I have ever owned, which is why F-Zero X is on there twice, as I used to own it on the N64, but sold it, and re-bought on the VC)

Four games of this gen are in my OVERALL TOP 10:

Mass Effect
Rock Band 2
Metal Gear Solid 4
Gears of War

So far...

MGS4
CoD4

Warhawk has managed to sneak into my top 10.

1. Gears of War*
2. Halo 2
3. Halo 3*
4. Mass Effect*
5. Halo CE
6. Halo Wars*
7. Left 4 Dead*
8. Bio Shock*
9. The Chronicles of Riddick Escape from Butcher Bay (havnt played dark athena yet)
10. Red Alert

So 6 of my top 10 games are from this Gen. Personally i dont care about nostalgia.