Who will win? I think Splinter Cell Conviction will sell 4-5 million similar to Assassins Creed. I think Uncharted 2 will sell 3-4 million doubling Uncharted 1

I meant Splinter Cell

I see Splinter Cell:Conviction at 3 million lifetime.

Uncharted 2, around 2.5 million lifetime.

Splinter Cell really went downward in its recent iterations (and may have lost fans)... so I'm gonna say uncharted.

Splinter Cell is a Huge franchise on Xbox. Remember, Double Agent was multiplat and came out when Xbox 360 only had a 5 million installed base. In no way could it have done fantastic numbers. The userbase just wasnt there.

Assassins Creed and Splinter Cell were both made by Ubisoft and share very similar gameplay styles. And Splinter Cell rocks!!!

 Its funnly how you dont even question me about the 4 million Uncharted 2 numbers I predicted even though the first only did about 2 million

I can see splinter cell doing a million and Uncharted doing 2 million. Splinter cell has never been a HUGE ip like AC turned out. I don't know why you'd suspect that to change now. The last Splinter Cell did 1.14 million according to this site and I don't see the next one being much different. If anything Doublt Agent had the benefit of coming out at a time with few big named exclusives but it will have more competition when conviction comes out.

Uncharted 2 to be around 4million.
Splinter Cell Conviction to be around 4million also.

Il say Uncharted 2 by a few thousand

Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell Ubisoft 2,325 N/A 2.93m 07th Oct 08

Splinter Cell sold nearly 3 million on the Xbox 1 alone.

Prolly tied.