MGS4 must be the best game ever, because i apparently claimed it is the best game this gen even though i don't recall ever saying it, but who am i to argue with megaman2 the leader?

I say Mass Effect owns MGS4.

Count me in.

I dont agree. Its a good game, but not great either.

And this comes from an MGS fan.

2nd to Muramasa imo.

Generally these conversaitons are limited to games that are actually ou-.....

Oh man

Importing must rule.

Anyway.

Gebx said that, did he?

 yea sure

we all know that you didnt play it

so why post?

The best game this generation is Uncharted, followed by Gears of War 2, then Dead Space. MGS4 is the worst Metal Gear game to date (well, its tied with MGS2).

Would it matter if he had? I did play it, and I'd say it's not the best game of this generation - I can think of at least one console exclusive game on every platform that I like better.

Is my opinion invalidated simply because I don't hold it as the best?