Who do You think would win in a fight? From what I can tell, they are around the same height, with Jack being slightly taller, due to the way he is hunched over. (I used foot-leg-and-weapon-sizing to resize and compare the two)
They are fighting in a cross-world. One half of the large room is In MadWorld, and the other half is in the GoW world (Similar to in MKvsDC)
Please pick one and LIST WHY
Jack is much stronger, (and after GoW2, quicker) than Marcus. There are plenty of examples (without giving out spoilers, such as the fact that he can lift up an entire row of theatre-type-seats and use them like a base-ball bat). Also, Jack will use any weapon he can find, whereas Marcus only use projectile weapons, his bayonnete, and grenades. Jack uses any weapon or object lying around. They can both carry only 2 main weapons. Jack can also use his chainsaw to deflect bullets, as seen in the game, and he would probably pick up guns that were lying around whenever they were in the GoW world. Both can curb stomp, chainsaw (duh), and they both have different methods of chainsawing... like behind-the-back, (for Jack, Decapitating), ect, and both have ways of "chainsaw dueling". However, whereas Jack can run faster, Marcus has the roll, which Jack does not, as well, as covering. They can both use human shields to an extent, but in this fight, there are no enemies around... This is a one-on-one fight. Also, Marcus has an active reload, while Jack has to wait for his chainsaw to reload. But, while Jack's secondary weapon never has to re-load, it breaks after a while, and he has to get another one.
Please vote, and remember to list why.
EDIT: Additional Details:
Most of MadWorld's levels (so far from what I've played) aren't outside During the day... They are inside, or outside during the night. Hammer of Dawn can only be used out in the open sky during the day right? Whenever the satelite is aligned? The time limit it has is similar to the most powerful weapon I have found yet in MadWorld, which is only out for a small amount of time during a bloodbath challenge... The Death Press II Hand. SO if the Hammer of Dawn could be used in the GoW world, then the DP2H could be used in his world. Basically, they would cancel out... So, in order to keep it interesting, Neither should be used... They can each hold two standard (read: Non-God) weapons, but can switch when necessary (But not just on-the fly, they have to go get the other weapon) Oh yeah, and both can use their telecommunication devices/radios. They haven't been jammed, like how they almost always were in GoW.
Current Score:
Jack Cayman: 6
Marcus Fenix: 4