It's a pretty different experience on the DS though as most missions use touch screen skills. The PDA is really cool.

In my opinion the sensors and feeling of the two controllers on Mad World are more effective than awkwardly shaking the PS3 controller.

It is difficult to know whether Mad World would have sold more on HD consoles as it hasn't been released and we can't use the success of other so-called hardcore games as this is a different title that could have more limited appeal. I can't say I see huge amounts of threads or petitions demanding the game be released on PS3 or 360. Anyone seen one?

Whether PS3 and Wii motion control are the same(I have no idea) is irrelevant. Because that would mean MadWorld would be PS3-exclusive, and I severely doubt the PS3 alone would sell better than it would on the Wii. Most people who say the game would sell better on PS3/360 than Wii back it up with "Well then it's on two consoles". I don't think a game like MadWorld would sell better on JUST the PS3 than it's going to on JUST the Wii. But if that's the claim you wanna make, then by all means, go right ahead.

I am far from a fanboy son. You are the one here with 29 posts.

In some games they are different, but there is not enough of a difference in Madworld to say that it can be done on one and not the other.

If 360 had motion I would be saying the same thing, except in that case you would be calling me a 360 fanboy.

I have been called all 3 plenty of times.

I don't think sales would be any different. I was only talking about "performing" in the gameplay sense.

The company behind Madworld isn't known for having very high selling titles.

Quality titles? Yes.

Oh, okay. Carry on, then.

It does register left and right swings, it also registers up and down swings as well as waggle. It depends on the context. Boss battles require specific directional movements and changes in speed of movement as well.

Can the DS3 do circle motions based on ir or thrust motion because both of these are in madworld and I don believe Ds3 can pull those motions off since it's basically a tilt dectector.

Well I read that Madworld does not make use of the IR pointer.

Yes, DS3 can do thrust motion. Like I said, in LAIR it was required to thrust your controller forward to perform a 180 degree turn. 

I know they are not exactly the same thing in every way, I am arguing that Madworld can easily be done on the PS3 and perform just as well. I am not saying it would perform better.

How about this then would rather shake the DS3 a hundred times in less than a minute or the wiimote?You do that heavily in madworld and I got tired shaking the DS3 in Folklore which by far has the most shaking required in any PS3 game.

The game uses two controllers as well. It uses circular motion, up and down motion, left and right motions, various speeds of motions. The motion sensing abilities are quite complex. I have no idea how sensitive the PS3 controller is, but it would need to be as good as the wiimote for it to work properly. It would also only be one controller which takes out then multi-handed approach of the game.