nice.

I really think they just want a game that plays well and is fun.

that really looks like they want to hurt the game.... 3.9 is very low on IGN.

I'm pretty sure you had a random character instead of sonic, the score would have been 6.9 and not 3.9. The guy seems angry at the speed of the game not being sonic speed...

... and he sure does hate "waggle"... why does this guy even review wii games??

Because there is a difference between intuitive, well thought and well done motino controls and tacked on waggle.

ouch, thats a low score.
Lets wait for more reviews.

true, but the term waggle is not really used by fans of intuitive, well though and well done motion controls... it's more used by wii haters.

That said, he would not coment on it if those controls were as you say intitive, etc...

How do you go from Sonic Adventure to this?

""You simply shake, shake and shake some more to slice enemies down as they approach. The title does not consider vertical or horizontal motion, so you can just waggle the controller mindlessly and win.""

So basically they inputed "move wiimote" for "press A button" I hardly see how this is bad... if the game does not aim at having any swordplay depth, this is all that is needed, it's a developper choice to make the game more kid friendly.... (so bad in HD gamer terms I guess??). He does point out lag in the controls, due to motion control (kinda comes with the territory).




"t's one of the worst control choices I've had to endure for any Wii game"

And that means all the waggle comments are indeed directed at the wii. Had the game been on PS2 and you had to press X instead it'd be a button masher and we know the score of these games, look at any DW review...

If I were reviewing the game, and the wii controls weren't any good. I would do readers wrong by not pointing that out.

Doesn't seem to stop reviewers on games off of the Wii haha.  You know what I'm talking about.  But oh come on dude your just agreeing with Matt because ya got a thing against the Wii.

My problem with the review, though isn't the score, but the way it was presented.  Shouldn't be about Matt's ideal Sonic game not being present but how the game actually is.  Can't get that from this review.  All you get from this review is a grown man whining.