I found all the Thief games more scary than Dead Space tbh, and Condemned is damn creepy!

Phantasmagoria.

Carl is now awesome.

i dont play many horror games, but no Silent Hill 4 is much more scary, Dead Space just surprises you, it isnt really that scary

hell no i didn't find dead space scary at all. scariest game of all time for me is Fatal Frame 2

When a was a kid, i found Metroid II pants filling scary. The same occured some years later with Super Metroid at the end of the game. Mother Brain rose menacingly and i was still recovering from the Giant Metroid scare earlier. Brrrrrrrrrr...

silent hill 1 & 2
Indeed

oh and clock tower was great to

silent hill 2 wasnt that scary

to me the number 1 is system shock 2 on pc, for the time, that was insane

other notables to me were fatal frame, sh4, and i thought fear 1 had some good moments, also yeh condemned 1, amazing.

I think fatal frame, siren and both condemned were far scarier then dead space. Anyone play clock tower on the ps2? "alisaaaaaaaaa", that scared the shot out of me everytime LOL