pastro243 said:
I agree with that, the US may be superior onl to Bolivia and Peru, but I doubt any otherteam in the region, maybe Venezuela, but they have gotten better in the last years. Your league is really bad, teams dont even descend if they finish last. And maybe you have more players than us, maybe they are bigger and faster, but technique is the most important thing. Players like Messi are small, and I dont even have to get to the point to name superstars, playes in my NT that are small areway better than yours.
Population may do something but its not that important. Uruguay is very small, still they are way better than the US.
Most kids in south america dream of being in their NT and playing the WC, especially in argentina and brazil, and that is how you make good players, they learn since they are small with passion.
|
Firstly I think we are definitely better right now than Peru and especially Bolivia. I think we are also pretty clearly above Venezuela. I think we are competitive with teams like Chile, Uruguay and Ecuador, maybe Paraguay. Definitely we are well behind Brazil and Argentina (although this is no shame for most teams in the world).
You don't know much about our league, I would guess. It is vastly improved since its founding in 1996. Players like David Beckham can come here and have a minimal impact. Perhaps closer to home, a player like Marcelo Gallardo played here in DC last season and did pretty well when he was healthy (not often enough, sadly), but hardly dominated every match. MLS is a decent league but still has a long way to go to challenge the top leagues in the world. It is not as good as the Mexican league at this point, although we are not too far below them. But the Mexican league is a very good league that challenges even in the Libertadores.
In any case, the bottom line is I feel you are underrating American players, MLS and the US national team, but I would not claim we would even necessarily qualify from the South American group in World Cup qualifiers - it would probably be close with those teams I mentioned above.