Wind Waker certainly has a unique charm that's almost impossible to resist but it was too short and too easy. Twilight Princess for me but both, as with all Zelda games i have played, are awesome.

Maaaaaaan why you gotta make me choooooooose

I'll say Wind Waker, God help me. It really was a masterpiece.

you are probably the only one besides me that i know who enjoyed it, the music, the changing weather,the beautiful graphics..man that was pure awesomeness.

I'm throwing in my hat! I loved the sailing to death!

Say it loud! Say it proud!

I LOVED THE SAILING IN WIND WAKER

I would go twilight princess, only because I prefer the 3D graphics over the cell shading, so I never bought windwaker. But I do have the phantom hourglass on DS, I like cartoony graphics on the DS, it really suites it, but I prefer nice 3D graphics on my TV :) I'm hoping the next zelda on the wii goes even harder with the 3D, I want something like a scaled back version of Fable II

WW was great all the way to when you had to find the tri-force peaces. It just got boring then… but it was a great game that would have been the best if it wasn’t for that and if it was a bit longer and harder.

TP is the better game. It had harder puzzles, more dungeons and just longer which what a Zelda game should be.

Shit I take it back Twilight Princess was really awesome and did have generally better dungeon design.

It was just missing something in comparison to Wind Waker. I don't know what.

I refuse to choose. But:

I LOVED THE SAILING IN WIND WAKER

yes it truly was a masterpiece!! i couldnt stop playing it! Best game last generation for me

maybe it was missing the charm only the wind waker had, it was a more lively world overall and although TP had better dungeons and overall better main quest, i felt WW more like a told tale in progress...if that make sense.

You can not undo what has been done! Now you have to live with it….Unless you have the ocarina of time ;)