brawl, although i did miss the 300 challenges that melee had, and which were imposible near the end

meh.

this thread is exactly why brawl is the dumbed down horrible game it is.

go play mario party.

melee for life fellas.

announcer voice: Tough call =/
Balance: Brawl is more balanced
ORIGINAL stage design: melee (too many pointless stages imo in brawl, but it was a close call)
extra features: brawl
most game breaking moves: melee (which is why tourney people like it, really?)
controls: either one, because i use gcn control on both
most pointless features: brawl (the game trial thing, seriously, why?)

brawl because of all the controller cusomtization and content

Brawl, characters seem more balanced. None of the characters in Brawl seem cheap or lousy.

I like the single player challenges in Melee better though. Sub Space in Brawl just wasn't my thing, felt really unorganized.

Brawl

1. Online play

2. More options for replay value

Fuck all of you brawl loving fagz. Brawl sux major dick and takes no skill to play. All I do to be good is play MK and spam the fuckin B button. All you scrub ass nubz need to learn how to play a real fighting game with real combos. and when I say combo, I don't fucking mean spam Nado with MK.

Fuck Brawl, It's a shitty ass game with a shitty ass game engine, and a shitty ass fan base. Fuck brawl....

Oh, and to all you retarded fuck nuts that think brawl dosn't have any "exploitable" glitches, you're fucking retarded. MK's Infinite Cape glitch ring a bell? Or are you all to fuckin stupid to know about it?

Brawl = Slow, Floaty, Lame, Gay, Dumb, Retarded, GAY!, no fun, 8 min matches, stall wars, camp wars, No skill, poorly made, fag fan base, alllll gaaaaaaaaaaaay, ez to be good at, horrible online play, MK tournaments, god I can go on forever..... But I have better things to do than bash this horrible ass game any longer. FUCK BRAWL AND FUCK ALL OF YOU!

Fuck all of you brawl loving fagz. Brawl sux major dick and takes no skill to play. All I do to be good is play MK and spam the fuckin B button. All you scrub ass nubz need to learn how to play a real fighting game with real combos. and when I say combo, I don't fucking mean spam Nado with MK.

Fuck Brawl, It's a shitty ass game with a shitty ass game engine, and a shitty ass fan base. Fuck brawl....

Oh, and to all you retarded fuck nuts that think brawl dosn't have any "exploitable" glitches, you're fucking retarded. MK's Infinite Cape glitch ring a bell? Or are you all to fuckin stupid to know about it?

Brawl = Slow, Floaty, Lame, Gay, Dumb, Retarded, GAY!, no fun, 8 min matches, stall wars, camp wars, No skill, poorly made, fag fan base, alllll gaaaaaaaaaaaay, ez to be good at, horrible online play, MK tournaments, god I can go on forever..... But I have better things to do than bash this horrible ass game any longer. FUCK BRAWL AND FUCK ALL OF YOU!

Brawl. I have to give it to brawl b/c is more balanced than meelee (in terms of the characters and their fighting skills)

BRAWL IS HORRIBLY DUMBED DOWN! FUCK BRAWL!