Supreme Commander is easily my 360 flop of the year. Just two weeks before it dropped to under 1k sales a week.

Golden Axe: Beastrider and Blacksite: Area 51 (tie) for the PS3.

Pimp My Ride for Wii wins too.

Too Human, Need for Speed, Mirror's Edge and Motorstorm 2.

Supreme Commander. Legendary I saw already got a price cut for most stores also.

Definitely Bioshock (PS3) for me. It shows that timed-exclusivity is almost as effective as exclusivity itself.

i'll go with too human.

Call of Duty 5 is a flop, but the best shooting game out there for the Wii (Behind MP3, of course)

FFS just say what you think is flop of year!

Flop is not about what you want it to mean. It means something that lost money. Even Okami was low budget enough that it made money.

That means half the items on that list are invalid. This is not up to debate.

The biggest flop is objectively Too Human.

Okami and No More Heroes really should be removed from your initial list. Both exceeded the developers expectations in terms of sales and were fairly well made. If you really want this to be a pure discussion of what is the worst flop of the year then I suggest removing all the games except what you think is the biggest flop.

Call of Duty made money on the Wii as well. The game used the same engine as the HD versions and the cost was shared. Plus considering Wii game costs, that means even by itself it would only have cost a few million, which those sales likely already made back.