Now over here, we have a hit and run troll comment. Fairly standard, especially from this particular user. Notice how he didn't mention whether he meant in Japan or worldwide, so that he can twist the statement later to fit his "expectations." Fancy stuff.

"The anatomy of a troll" is rather interesting, I do learn new things on this forum every day.

My bad...  I was just quickly glancing at posts in this thread and saw some Star Ocean 4 comments so I thought it was fair game.  What's really funny in retrospect is that I thought Leo-J's comment about selling over 1 million was about Star Ocean 4.

I won't mention the game in this thread again.

Why is this a surprise?

The number of PS3s in Japan easily tops the number of 360s. Of course it would be the largest HD JRPG in Japan ever released... its like.. the PS3's first JRPG. (I don't count Folklore and VC as traditional JRPGs)

I need to borrow that one, I won't be able to troll properly untill Ive read it.

I mean I have seen some shining examples in this thread that I cant imagine competing with without the proper knowledge.

Nice analysis. 

 Why haven't Wii JRPGS sold tons then?

I think star ocean 4 will do better than everyone expects(Has nothing to do with the thread, just to reply to legend), if it gets good reviews, it will sell in the west, its pretty hyped up by the 360 fans on the forums.

It's Quite amusing that every thread that doesn't have to do with Wii DS or PSP, someone always has to bring them in.

That's completely irrelevant.  Demographics?  Quality?  Lots of reasons?

The HD JRPGs should all have the about same potential for quality.  It should come as no surprise that, if WKC is a quality title, it should vastly outsell any 360 JRPGs in Japan.